Premium Essay

Changes and Implications to Griffiths Study

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By Tashamoore15
Words 311
Pages 2
Suggest 2 improvements that could be made to the Griffiths study and outline any implications these changes may have. (8)

One change would be to replicate the study in different countries. Pseudo patients could see if they would be diagnosed as having schizophrenia by doctors in England, France and Canada. The pseudo patients would provide the same symptoms as in the original study (thud, hollow and empty). This would allow the researcher to investigate any cross cultural differences in diagnosis and the treatment of patents (if admitted to a hospital).

An implication of this may be that doctors in the other countries may make the same mistakes with diagnosis thus showing practitioners to be bias cross cultural. This would give further support for the need of the DSM to be updates and would mean that the results form Rosenhan's study could be generalised to other countries. In addition to this it would provide insight into treatments used in the different countries, they may find that the type of care/ standard of care differ from country to country (possibly worse in counties with lower economy)

Another improvement could be to set up CCTV cameras into the hospitals to record the behaviours of the staff towards the patients. This would be overt at first as the staff would be aware the cameras are being brought in, however they would soon forget they are there. This would allow Rosenhan to have a record of staff patient interaction and the treatment of the pseudo patients.

An implication of this would be that staff may treat the patients very well as they are aware of the cameras initially. They may interact more to be seen as being good careers. The observational footage could also be used to validate comments made by the pseudo patients as they could compare the video footage with their self…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

An in-Depth Study of Counseling in Organizations: Causes and Implications

...Running head: WORKPLACE COUNSELING An In-depth Study of Counseling in Organizations: Causes and Implications Goh Chong Ying Student ID S10063597D Ngee Ann Polytechnic An in-depth study of counseling in organizations: Causes and implications According to Carroll (1996), in current workplace situation, workers are working longer hours than before with no additional capital support and there might be chances that employees are doing the same amount of work with lesser pay, hence many employees face a high level of stress (p. 1). Many tried to overcome it. At the same time, employers and health professionals are also trying to help the employees in searching for new methods in handling stress and unavoidable after effects (Carroll, 1996, p. 1). There are many benefits for employers to be more concern on both the physical and mental health of the workers. Companies, who have healthy employees, tend to do well. It will increase the profits of the company and improve the superiority of the goods and services. Thus, Carroll (1996) reported that an increase is seen in providing amenities for workers to keep themselves fit physically and mentally (p. 3). According to Carrol (1996), some organizations provide internal counseling, external counseling, and education for workers in stress management (p. 3). In this report, causes, effectiveness and benefits of counseling will be covered. Firstly, one of the reasons why counseling is necessary in a workplace environment is......

Words: 1944 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Change and Culture Case Study

...significant reduction in workforce and redesign specific departments within the system. A redesign of the patient care delivery system within an organization can result from many issues such as the continued increase in health care costs, patient safety or quality concerns, or workforce shortages. This paper will discuss how an organization begins the process of job redesign, and what work processes and performance expectations must be considered once the design is implemented. It will identify the steps and structures that the organization will put in place to make it a true learning organization that will encourage the staff to adapt and excel in spite of the changes. Moreover, it will talk about how to plan and control intra- and inter-organizational communications that must occur to implement the job design changes. Lastly, how management can ensure individual job satisfaction for this position. The process of job redesign begins with conducting a system analysis. A system analysis provides an understanding of how the system works and the different elements in the system interact. In the healthcare system, this analysis helps to improve the interface between different components or personnel of that system in order to enhance the functioning of each individual component within the total organization. There are ten steps in considering the process of a job redesign (Henrisken, Battles, Marks, 2008). The first step is to decide which to decide which system would be the......

Words: 1182 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

The Implication of Hawthorne Study in 21st Century

...Assignment The Implication of Hawthorne Study in 21st Century Ashab Anis Joy ID: 2012-1-10-255 Class: MGT Course Code: 101 Sec: 7 Semester: Fall East West University Bachelor of Business Administration East West University 20th November 2012 Introduction The Hawthorne Experiments were conducted between 1927 and 1932 at the works of the Western Electric Company in Chicago. Basically the aim of these experiments was to ” attempt to reduce worker dissatisfaction and resist trade union influence by the putting in place of a paternalistic package of social and recreational benefits calculated to sustain workers “loyalty” (Sheldrake 105:1996). Many little assignments were conducted in hope of putting into practice the above theory. Despite the economic progress brought about in party by Scientific Management, critics were calling attention to the severe labour/management conflict, apathy, boredom, and wasted human resources. These concerns lead a number of researchers to examine the discrepancy between how an organisation was supposed to work versus how the workers actually behaved. In addition, factors like World War I, developments in psychology (e.g. Freud) and later the depression, all brought into question some of the basic assumptions of the Scientific Management School. One of the primary critics of the time, Elton Mayo, claimed that this ‘alienation’ stemmed from the breakdown of the social structures caused by industrialisation, the factory system, and its......

Words: 4408 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Implication of Strategic Change in British Airways

...Abstract Business strategy is important for organizations to operate, and it significantly impacts on every department of organizations. If the strategy has changed, it will cause many problems. In the process of implementing these changes, there is support or resistance from shareholders. This report focuses on analyzing BA’s strategic changes and dealing with managing these changes. In tradition, HRM is the organizational function that deals with requirement, training, assessment and rewarding of employees, while also managing people and the workplace culture and environment. Now the new role of HRM refers to overcome the challenge form implementing changes of organizational strategies. The case also indicates that the flexible HRM plays a significant role of dealing with the disputes between employees and management. Key words: strategy management, British Airways, change management, labor dispute Implication of strategic change in British Airways 1. Introduction Generally, a company makes strategies based on the changing environment. But if the strategies changes, there are many barriers to conduct. Human resource is performed as the most valuable asset of organizations. How to manage and more efficiently utilize the asset is so significant for organization to operate and develop. Obviously, there are resistance form employees. Therefore, human resource department is responsible for coordination in the organization.......

Words: 3419 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Change and Culture Case Study

...Change and Culture Case Study I Alesha Nesbeth HCS/514 September 9, 2013 Vinnette Batiste Change and Culture Case Study I The following paper will discuss the effects of merging a healthcare organization with a competitor. For the purpose of this paper the companies will be addressed as company A, company B, and company C. The following paper will discuss the merger in detail in regards to restructuring and the effect of the sale on the company as a whole as well as the culture and values of these two companies. A merger is the combining of two or more corporate entities to create one new organization with one licensure and one provider number for reimbursement purposes (Lielber & McConnell, 2008). In the case of company A and company B this is a Horizontal merger. Horizontal merger is a business consolidation that occurs between firms who operate in the same space, often as competitors offering the same good or service. Horizontal mergers are common in industries with fewer firms, as competition tends to be higher and the synergies and potential gains in market share are much greater for merging firms in such an industry ("Investopedia-Horizontal Merger", 2013). Mergers do not happen every day however; when they do it is for a variety of reasons. Such reasons as: the desire to increase size so as to have greater clout in negotiations with managed care providers who tend to bypass smaller enterprises; the desire to penetrate new markets to attract......

Words: 1566 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Change and Culture Case Study

...Change and Culture Case Study II HCS/514 July 29, 2013 Brian Eigelbach Change and Culture Case Study II The increasing demand for improving patient care delivery and reducing costs in an intensely competitive industry forces organizations consider various strategies relating to restructuring. Restructuring strategies include mergers and acquisitions, staff downsizing and redefining the scope of duties and responsibilities of the employee role within the organization. When companies decide to merge sometimes radical decisions are made regarding the vision and mission of the new organization. At the start of the merger the main focus is the blending of the organization and the cultures within the organization. Managers face many obstacles during the blending process. Some of the challenges include lack of planning, staff resistance to change and failure to constantly reevaluate the changes made. It is very important during the blending of the two organizations management continue to monitor the change and determine if the process needs further adjustment in order for the new organization to meet the revised mission and goals. It is during this evaluation period that management may determine that further change is necessary and sometimes that change requires drastic staff downsizing and revised responsibilities of staff. This paper will re-examine the fictional organization from Case Study I six months after the merger of two competing healthcare......

Words: 1885 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Study of Organizational Behaviour Change

...International has built a reputation of immeasurable quality, service excellence, integrity and being pioneers in innovation. 1.2 Objectives of the Study The objective is to study the organizations structure, internal and external environment, carry out an analysis of the strengths and weaknesses, discovering new opportunities and finding out the threats faced by Marriott International. Furthermore, we would also be assessing whether the organizational structure implemented by the company is apt for today’s volatile, unpredictable and fast moving environment. 1.3 Scope of the study In this report we intend to focus majorly on the organizational structure and the assessment of the internal and external environment. This report would not cover the competitor analsysis in depth and would be limited to the study on Marriott International as a whole. Moreover, we have not taken into account the different styles of operations carried out by the franchises at different parts of the world. Minor variations are seen in the working of the company at different geographical locations to suit the needs of those particular regions. 1.4 Limitation of the study The data collected from the secondary sources for the making of this report is a year old. This limits the study in some ways since the changes in this present year could prove to be significant. Moreover, Marriott International’s presence throughout the globe, and their local operations aimed at......

Words: 1443 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Change Management Case Study

...Change Management case study: Health line Pharmaceuticals is one of the traditional family run medium size company doing business in Thailand. Started by Hirati Mioka in 1973, the company expanded steadily till 1997 by launching new products across Thailand and in different parts of Malaysia, Vietnam, Myanmar, Bangladesh, Indonesia and Philippines. The company has the core competency in making generic drugs for the entire nation. However, with the entry of the large global multinationals in the region like UK based Glaxo Smithkline, Germany based Novartis, India based Sun Pharma, China based Hepa link Pharmaceutical etc., the company started facing difficulty. From 1973 till 1990, the business of Health line grew at the rate of 23% on an average per year, which increased to the level of 31-33% per annum till 1997. However, this phenomenal growth started declining since 1999. During 1999-2010, the growth rate reduced to only 6%-7% per annum. By 1986, the next generation of Mioka family took over the helm of affairs of the company, who were more radical and liberal minded than their ancestors. They were western qualified and had the exposure to modern medicine and pharma research, being held in USA and Europe. They had close interaction through professional channels with some of the greatest pharmaceutical entrepreneurs of Asia such as Li Li of Hepa link Pharmaceuticals, Dilip Sanghvi of Sun Pharmaceuticals etc. However, this second generation could not come out of their......

Words: 1112 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Change and Culture Case Study

...Change and Culture Case Study HCS/514 Version 2 December 19, 2011 Sara Brown Culture Communication and policy standard will be a huge piece of the integration. Communication will have to flow from top to bottom and horizontal among the mid level managers. Part of the communication piece will be setting the standard. If the purchased organization had different standard the employees will revert to those standard until new standard are presented to them. The culture often takes on that of the organization that purchases another; there are many processes in place that may not allow for complete integration of the employees of the sold company, into that of the purchasing company. The culture will be set from the beginning and it will be important to put into practice the two cultures so the other organization feel as if they are part of the new organization. There are services that the sold organization provides that the purchasing company does not have and may be unfamiliar with. Within such services are professionals and departments that may have their own strong mini cultures within the larger corporate culture. There will be competition between staff of both organizations, as those from each are most comfortable with their own cultures and try to maintain their current status. The mid level managers of the two organizations need to work together and see what services will work best. Being open minded and using some of......

Words: 1215 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Griffith

...Griffith’s statement, “ There is no hope for perfect research” which was coined in 1998, has started another debacle altogether rather than answering this ongoing question itself. Who know what’s the right answer of correct value of pie (3.14) One can agree easily on the fact that it was the pursuit of correct answer and a perfect one not to mention which made us just not be content on having candles for lighting purposes but discover electricity. The definition of research, is “a detailed study of a subject, especially in order to discover (new) information or reach a (new) understanding.” ( www.webs.uidaho.edu) The definition itself says a new answer providing new set of knowledge, certainly not the ;ast answer which may not allow further research. Research is an continuous fire which is fueled by man’s desire of perfect solution. Since we human are subject to flaws, that trait of ours is also reflected in our work as well. It is a process of searching again and again till the right answer is found. Earlier it was believed that the earth is oval. It was a continuous voyage of discovery and experiments which proved it wrong after decades. The main objective of research is not to find the last answer but to find out the facts which are concealed and not known to us as of now. Every discovery or invention that we see or use in today’s world is a result of an ongoing research which continued for a long time and then ended up in providing us a better solution. Had we......

Words: 820 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Business Implications of Climate Change

...Business Implications of Climate Change The Case of Phillips Van-Heusen Corporation 2/28/2012 INTROUCTION Along with the stresses of making a business profitable for investors, minimizing costs, raising revenues, and forecasting for growth, one factor that is especially difficult to predict are those incurred by human caused climate change, commonly known as global warming. It is expected that the effects of global warming will greatly affect numerous aspects of the business world. However, not all of the effects are necessarily bad. In fact, it allows for opportunities to better these companies. In this case, the focus will be on global warming’s effects on Phillips Van-Heusen Corporation (PVH). In order to properly attend to this topic, a brief description of PVH, possible threats, opportunities, and an overall conclusion of global warming’s effects on the company will be addressed. To start, we will take a brief look into PVH Corporation as a whole. PHILLIPS VAN-HEUSEN CORPORATION PVH is a large clothing company that owns popular lines such as Tommy Hilfiger, Calvin Klein, Arrow, Van-Heusen, and many more. The major focus is marketing moderately high end clothing. This company tends to focus its clothing lines towards males, however, there are a few lines focused towards women. These clothes range from lounge wear to business suits and everything in between. PVH also produces and sells clothing accessories such as belts, wallets, sunglasses, scarves, etc.......

Words: 1175 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Change and Case Study 1

...defined, and develops organically over time from the cumulative traits of the people the company hires. A company's culture will be reflected in its dress code, business hours, office setup, employee benefits, turnover, hiring decisions, treatment of clients, client satisfaction and every other aspect of operations." It is paramount that management try to establish a positive atmosphere immediately and establish policies and procedures for it's employees to promote a work environment that will benefit the company over time.Knowing what tools are available will help make the transition for your company a great one. A lot of times, company merge to become more competitive . The consolidation of these May seem difficult because the culture change. Normally the two entities function differently by way of operation, closing the knowledge gap is very important.  When information is shared between the two companies it makes the whole organization better. Utilizing programs to show how effectively the company is operating can help show areas of concern. These can be accessed and addressed in a timely fashion . Because each side would like for the company to thrive, they work together . During this merger roles of the employees / department should be clearly defined . As with anything the lack if knowledge or understanding is what cause failure. As I have started before knowing when employees are aware of their roles and how to do them effectively thing run much more smoothly......

Words: 791 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Change and Culture Case Study

...Change and Culture Case Study Two Managing in today’s Health Care Organizations HCS/514 Change and Culture Case Study Two The basic principle in designing jobs is to create jobs that employees enjoy performing because the job is naturally appealing. There are several ways to which designing jobs can be performed efficiently, pleasant, and enjoyable ("Designing jobs that motivate," nd). There are five important job dimensions, skill variety, task identity, task significance, autonomy, and feedback ("Designing jobs that motivate," nd). A learning organization is one where employees continually expand their abilities to create desired results (Smith, 2001). Designing jobs must start with the review of information views. Systems thinking are the theoretical framework which provides information to help understand factors that are involved in change allowing for clearer understanding of how to facilitate the process (Smith, 2001). With organizations facing falling reimbursements and climbing costs for services, they face the hard decision of doing more for less. Process of Job Design The redesign of an organization has several steps. The first step in the organization design process is designing principles that would be applied to certain situations ("Application of principles," nd). The ideas surrounding the first step are skills, abilities, needs, and motivation. The design team will help to formulate an acceptable model of the employee behavior......

Words: 1457 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Climate Change Implications for the Pacific Islands

...Climate change implications for the Pacific Islands Across the planet now we see ever more flood, ever more drought, ever more storms. People are dying, communities are being wrecked and local plants and species are being wiped away — the impacts we’re already witnessing from climate change are unlike anything we have ever seen before. There is report that identifies small island states as being the most vulnerable countries of the world to the adverse impacts of climate change. The Pacific is in fact without a doubt one of the world’s most vulnerable regions when it comes to risk of disaster due to climate change, particularly several of the low-lying coral islands. Climate change is already affecting Pacific Islands with dramatic revenue loss across sectors such as agriculture, water resources, forestry, tourism and other industry-related sectors. Some of the projected impacts of climate change on main sectors that specifically apply to the Pacific Islands are listed below. (reference here) Agriculture is extremely vulnerable to climate change, with high temperature levels reducing yields of desirable crops and changes in precipitation patterns increasing crop failures (reference here). Pacific islands are constantly being exposed to these threats of climate change and we have already witnessed the effects of these threats. For example the different weather variations occurring in different parts of the pacific islands, low levels of our crops and forestry......

Words: 932 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Change and Case Study 1

...Change and Culture Case Study I Lydia Wooten Managing in Today’s Health Care Organizations HCS/513 September 17, 2012 Darlene Cantu Change and Culture Case Study I There are many reasons why mergers take place. The main reason why corporation exists with merging with companies is to enhance their level of competition in the market. It is however important to note that conjuring departments into a single organizational unit is a different form of merging. This is due to the fact that the cultural transformation may not be as great as merging two companies. The major challenge involved with merging is getting two different groups or staff to work collaboratively to realize real benefits. In this scenario, am a middle manager in a healthcare organization that has merged with a previous competitor, Competition has been viewed to result to delivery of poor quality of care. One unique aspect about the new organization is the fact that it has in place numerous outpatient and inpatient services that our organization does not. This paper will be described what affects the organization will have on the culture on terms of systems and shapes. In detail provide quality care from the middle manager to ensure the staff will ensure quality care without a competitive point of view. Impact Sale on the Culture of the New Combined Organization T-Mobile and AT&T are similar organization but they provide different services. The same scenario for health care organization......

Words: 1848 - Pages: 8