Free Essay

Critically Evaluate the Comparative Transnational Effectiveness of Benetton and Zara

In: Business and Management

Submitted By hailey0214
Words 2091
Pages 9
Critically evaluate the comparative transnational effectiveness of Benetton and Zara

Zara and Benetton are two of the most acknowledged clothing companies in the fast fashion industry. The different international business strategies they adopt result in different transnational effectiveness. To begin with, this essay will give a brief overview of the motivation, means and mentality of these two companies, and then compare how they sustain their competitive advantages through integration, responsiveness and flexibility. Next, it will highlight their evolving strategies and demonstrate the structures, worldwide learning and innovation models they adopt to support the strategies. Finally, the evolving global roles will be analyzed.
Motivation, Means and Mentality
As well-known leading clothing corporates, Zara and Benetton both choose to expand aboard. Although their motivations to internationalize are quite similar, their means and mentalities are different in many ways.
Basically, there are two kinds of motivations: traditional motivations and emerging motivations. The biggest traditional factor that drives Zara and Benetton to expand aboard is market-seeking. The former CEO of Inditex, Jose Maria Castellano, pointed out that the limited market growth potential in domestic market was the main driver for Zara to go aboard (Martinez, 1997). In 1988, Zara opened its first overseas store in Oporto, Portugal as the first step to occupy global market (Lopez and Fan, 2009). Nowadays it has expanded into 88 countries and has more than 6,500 shops worldwide (Ruddick, 2014). Like Zara, Benetton set up its first overseas retail store only one year after the opening of 3 domestic shops. In 2009, foreign market accounts for around half of Benetton’s overall sales (Palladino, 2010). Zara and Benetton’s global expansion is also driven by emerging motivations. They both capture global demand to achieve scale economies. Because Zara and Benetton competes in a fast fashion industry, they focus on producing some basics that can meet universal needs and sells aboard to achieve economies of scale.
Although Zara and Benetton carry the similar motivation to global expansion, they enter global market in different modes. Zara mainly uses wholly-owned subsidiary to achieve internationalization. By contrast, Benetton usually takes the form of
1
franchising and licensing. It is the first Italian fast fashion corporate that uses the quasi-franchising system to retailing (Crestanello and Tattara, 2009). Mentality refers to company’s strategy to go aboard. In general, Zara is evolving from global mentality to transnational mentality, while Benetton is witnessing the transformation from international mentality to global mentality.
Developing Transnational Strategies
Initially, ZARA and Benetton adopted Global Strategy and International Strategy respectively, for achieving the goals of global efficiency, flexibility and global learning.
Firstly, for achieving the global efficiency, both ZARA and Benetton take the advantage of national differences by centralizing the capital-intensive production, meanwhile, transferring partial labor-intensive activities in relatively low labor cost countries. For example, ZARA conducts about 64% of the production within the Spain radius area for protecting the production know-how, with 36% of the production of basic styles in Asia and Africa to reduce the production cost. Comparatively, Benetton mostly controls 80% of its production at home to enjoy the accession to superior domestic textile, with 20% of its basic products’ production in other regions (Decken, 2010). Additionally, the two companies pursue economies of scales in different ways. For example, ZARA triples other competitors’ annual sales by offering limited quantity but diversified choices to fashion-oriented customers to spread production costs. On the contrary, Benetton produces a considerable amount of garments dyeing with multiple colors but in limited styles, at the same time beats the competitors with the superior textile and dyeing quality, it enjoys higher margin from the standardized production with higher pricing (Fox, 2011).
Secondly, in terms of pursuing global flexibility, ZARA and Benetton adopt different entry modes to realize different levels of risk aversion. As mentioned above, ZARA expands mainly through wholly owned subsidiaries to guarantee tightly controlled and globally standardized operation. Benetton, by contrast, expands typically through franchising and licensing to avoid the macro risks of specific markets.
2
Thirdly, in regard to global learning, these two companies adopts different innovation models. ZARA aims to ‘discover’ and ‘reactively follow’ the fashion trends emerging globally, while Benetton proactively ‘create’ the fashion trends with exploring its own innovations. Details will be given later.
On balance, both ZARA and Benetton provide standardized products to the world markets. Nevertheless, due to different pricing and different capabilities, ZARA turns out to adopt the Global Strategy as it faces slightly higher pressure of cost reduction than Benetton. In contrast, Benetton preempts the competitors with excellent quality and superior technology through the International Strategy.
Notwithstanding, both strategies evolve for strengthening the competitive advantages and building blocks for competitors. ZARA, comparing with Benetton, differentiates itself with increasing customer responsiveness, thus transforms to Transnational

3
Strategy (Figure 1). By making good use of its capabilities like telecommunication information system, Zara makes sure the instant weekly tracking of different regions’ preferences with slightly adjusted offerings (Horn and Faulkner, 2010). These reduce the inventory cost of the unsalable product, besides, increase the sales margin by customer satisfaction. In terms of Benetton, even though it has the advantages of exclusive technology and superior quality, the cost and prices pressure from the emerging competitors like H&M and ZARA have forcing Benetton to further cut its cost, therefore chasing after Global Strategy instead, to be better off in the competition. For example, evidence shows that Benetton’s low cost advantage with JIT supported production (inventory cost 18% over total sales), almost surpassed by ZARA’s complex customer responsive oriented JIT system (inventory cost less than 10% over total sales) (Hill, and Jones, 2012).
Developing a Transnational Organization
To manage and support the process of changes in the strategies, Zara and Benetton applied different structures. Zara used to develop a centralized hub to support its global strategy. It centralized its core capabilities and resources, and made decisions at home, while regarded the subsidiaries as the delivery pipelines to the global market. For example, the factories in Europe produced more complex and fast fashion products, leaving standard products produced in Asia (Lopez and Fan, 2009). One reason is that Zara considered that European consumers were more enthusiastic about fashion and shared the same taste. For another reason, Zara aimed to retain its competitive advantages, such as cost leadership, quality assurance and quick response to fashion trend, all of which required the company to have a tight control over operation and decision making (Jose, 2010). To achieve this, Zara established the integrated supply chain and maintained its key business elements, namely design, manufacture, logistics and distribution around headquarter in Spain.
To conform to the evolving Transnational Strategy, Zara is transforming to the integrated network structure, in which each subsidiary is regarded as a source of knowledge, ideas, resources and capabilities. Therefore, Zara’s global stores are responsible for sensing the dynamic local customer demands and sending the information directly to headquarter in Spain (Hume, 2011). Furthermore, this
4
structure is facilitated by Zara’s advanced information system, which transfers the customer and inventory information among all the business units and contributes to the design and production decisions of the company.
Unlike Zara, in the 1990s, Benetton started to adopt coordinated federation structure so that it could implement international strategy more efficiently. During this period, Benetton’s leading position in fashion market was challenged by emerging rivals such as Zara, H&M and Gap, and its resources and capabilities were no longer competitive (Jose, 2010). Accordingly, it was forced to leverage its manufacturing capabilities and transfer parent technology and expertise to local subsidiaries. Although the overall coordination was controlled by headquarter, Benetton delegated part of its responsibilities and gave autonomy to local subsidiaries to adapt local differences. To alleviate cost reduction pressure resulting from the fiercer competition, Benetton transforms to Global Strategy and Centralized Hub Structure. The significant concepts of design and production are kept in the centre and the job for the subsidiaries is just producing the standardized products.
Worldwide Learning and Resulting Effective Innovation
Generally, Zara has been transferring from the traditional innovation model of centre- for-global to the transnational one of locally leveraged. In regard to the central innovations, the design teams of Zara gather sufficient inspiration from the world's ‘big-four-fashion-week’ and then design new styles within in a few days in headquarter. New styles are produced in-house and then distributed uniformly across Zara stores all over the world. Zara makes such central innovation effective through its advanced hybrid information and communication system. In terms of gaining subsidiary input and responding to national needs, Zara gives store managers significant autonomy in product display and inventory management within their stores and relies on store managers to feed back market research and store trends to design teams in headquarter (Tan, 2010). Such information transfer process allows Zara to keep pace with the ever-changing fashion trend and continuously launch new products to meet customer demand.
5
Zara’s central innovation has also been supplemented by the evolving locally leveraged innovations. Zara has brought the Asian fashion trends to the British high street. For example, the Kurta kind blouse was initially designed specially for the Middle East and South Asian markets. Following its popularity and success in these markets, Zara launched this kind of clothes in the United Kingdom. Finally, Asian fashion became the mainstream fashion this season on the British high street thanks to Zara (Khan, 2014).
In contrast, Benetton is still striving to make the central innovations effective. Every year, Benetton’s design centre in Italy selects innovative ideas from Fabrica, a communication research centre, and combines them with market trends to create new seasonal collections for its franchisers around the world. Recent years, to better manage this centre-for-global process, Benetton has established directly operated stores to strengthens the retail network and transmit feedbacks on sales and consumer preference from retailers directly to headquarter (Jose, 2010). This action helps Benetton gain subsidiary input into centralized activities and greatly improves the effectiveness of the central innovation.
An Evolving Global Role
To enable their own transnational enterprises to sustain effectiveness, Zara and Benetton take into account their roles and responsibilities in the global context with the expansion penetrating. Zara is more like an exploitive MNE that leveraged low- cost factors of production to capture competitive advantage regardless of its responsibility for negative impact on emerging countries. Zara created more eco- friendly products and made a commitment to Greenpeace to eliminate release of hazardous chemicals into environment (Greenpeace, 2012). Nevertheless, it was more notorious of using sweatshops in many countries such as Argentina and Brazil in which the wages were significantly lower than those in developed countries, so were the working conditions, the safety standards, and even the human rights of the workers. Therefore, consumers worldwide boycotted Zara products. To cope with this situation, Zara seeks to collaborate with NGOs, unions and business associations to train labors and also improve pay level and working conditions to make itself more responsive (Alexander, 2013).
6
Nevertheless, Benetton is more like a transformative MNE that takes a larger role in developing countries to mitigate the massive issues that their population and government face. Although Benetton had been involved in sweatshop scandals, they demonstrated that they improved working conditions and worked on Corporate Social Responsibility policy (The Guardian, 2011). Furthermore, Benetton concentrates on public awareness of social and global issues such as AIDS, war and poverty. An illustration is that in 1993, Benetton initiated a special project to distribute second- hand clothing to the poor, cooperating with the International Federation of the Red Cross and other NGOs (Bryan and David, 2011). Benetton also launched a campaign working together with Senegal’s musician to promote micro-credit to alleviate the poverty in Africa (Seagraves, 2008).
To conclude, Zara and Benetton perform quite different in global market. Although they are driven by similar motivations, they enter overseas market in different modes and pursue distinct mentalities. Considering their degrees of integration, responsiveness and flexibility, Zara is in the process of transforming from global strategy to transnational strategy, while Benetton is evolving from international strategy to global strategy. Zara and Benetton adjust their organizational structure in accordance to their strategies. Besides, Zara evolves innovation model from centre- for-global to locally leveraged, but Benetton still makes efforts to realize efficient central innovations. In general, Zara is viewed as a benchmark in fast fashion industry and outperforms Benetton. Nevertheless, Zara nowadays suffers from the scandal of using sweatshops, while Benetton is highly committed to corporate social responsibility.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Critically Evaluate Locke’s Argument Against Innate Ideas

...Critically Evaluate Locke’s Argument against Innate Ideas In the enquiry, Locke talks of the notion of innate ideas as being ‘an established opinion amongst some men,’ this opinion can be seen as a direct conflict with Locke’s empiricism. Locke’s philosophical standpoint is that the mind gains ideas and concepts solely through experience; he argues that when we are born, we are born tabula rasa, a blank slate free from any knowledge or understanding and it is as we grow and experience the world around us that we form knowledge. The notion of innate ideas and principles then is clearly in complete contrast with Locke’s epistemology and as such Locke needs to show the arguments in favour of innate ideas to be flawed. I will show how Locke focuses his attack on one major assertion for the innate concept thesis, known as the great argument; how his two major problems with this argument are unfounded and how we can hold onto the concept of innate ideas in light of Locke’s criticisms. The great argument which Locke views as the main argument in favour of innate ideas goes as such: 1: If a principle is universally accepted then it is innate (as are the ideas which make it up) 1 2: There are some principles which are universally accepted 3: These principles (and the ideas which make them up) are innate This argument can be seen as fairly self-explanatory, but it does seem to rely completely on two major assumptions. Firstly, that all universally accepted principles must be......

Words: 1664 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Benetton and Zara

...Títol: Benetton and Zara information systems:a comparative analysis Volum:I de I Alumne: Chiara Pirone Director/Ponent:Jose M.Cabré Garcia Departament:Organización de Empresas Data: 28 Junio 2010 DADES DEL PROJECTE Títol del Projecte:Benetton and Zara information systems:a comparative analysis Nom de l'estudiant:Chiara Pirone Titulació:Ingenieria superior Informatica Crèdits: 37.5 Director/Ponent:Jose M.Cabré Garcia Departament:Organización de Empresas MEMBRES DEL TRIBUNAL President:Ferran Sabate Carriga Toma de decisiones y gestión de proyectos empresariales(PDGPE) Vocal:Francesc Tiñena Salvañà Compresion de datos e imagen (CDI) Secretari:Jose M. Cabré Garcia Empresa y entorno economico(EEE) QUALIFICACIÓ Qualificació numèrica: Qualificació descriptiva: Data: INDEX CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION CHAPTER 2: VERTICAL INTEGRATION 2.1. VERTICAL INTEGRATION 2.2:  THE  THREE  A’S  OF  A  SUPPLY  CHAIN  EXCELLENCE 2.2.1: AGILITY 2.2.2: ADAPTABILITY 2.2.3: ALIGNMENT 2.3:  PORTER’S  ANALYSIS 2.4: EXAMPLES: WAL-MART AND DELL CHAPTER 3: THE SYSTEM LOCK-IN 3.1 THE DELTA MODEL 3.2: THE SYSTEM LOCK-IN 3.3: EXAMPLE: FORD MOTOR CO 3.3.1: FORD MOTOR CO LOCK-IN CHAPTER 4 : ZARA 4.1 ZARA’S  HISTORY 4.2 BUSINESS MODEL 4.2.1:  PORTER’S  ANALYSIS  ON  ZARA 4.2.2 PRODUCT LIFE CYCLE CURVE 7 9 9 13 15 16 17 19 30 36 36 39 41 42 45 45 47 47 49 1 4.2.3: KEY FACTORS OF SUCCESS 4.2.4: STRATEGIC DRAWBACKS 4.2.5: LOGISTICS AND SUPPLY CHAIN 4.2.6: STRATEGY 4.2.7: OPPORTUNITIES 4.3 THE......

Words: 43564 - Pages: 175

Premium Essay

Choose One Global Crime as a Case Study and Critically Evaluate the Effectiveness of the Transnational Policing of This Crime.

...Choose one global crime as a case study and critically evaluate the effectiveness of the transnational policing of this crime. This essay focuses on money laundering and argues the effectiveness of the transnational policing of this crime; money laundering is one of the world’s most prevailing organised crimes. This essay firstly defines policing from contrasting viewpoints of different philosophers as well as identifying modes of the police. I will explore the modes of policing and various definitions of policing; this essay considers definitions and approaches to policing through a transnational concept with influences from prominent figures within the ideology of transnational policing. The conventional process of money laundering is clarified together with implications of the how this global crime effects other crimes as well as society as a whole. Aided with two case studies I give examples of how money laundering takes place; taking into hindsight the effectiveness of the policing of money laundering. This essay also addresses the connection between money laundering and the risk society theory whilst also taking into consideration the contrasting views of domestic police modes and transnational police modes. Through addressing ways in which money laundering is combated through global organisations such as Interpol, I critically address significant notions of the policing of money laundering. Policing is typically understood as a method of crime control; however......

Words: 3023 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Critically Evaluate the Factors Influencing the Global Heat Budget

...CRITICALLY EVALUATE THE FACTORS INFLUENCING THE GLOBAL HEAT BUDGET - 40 MARKS The global heat budget is the balance between incoming insolation, and outgoing radiation from Earth. There are many factors that influence this heat budget, some of which are more important than others. In this essay I am going to describe and explain each factor involved. Insolation is the incoming energy from the sun in shortwave ultraviolet (UV) radiation. The distribution of insolation over the Earth’s surface is complicated; however there are patterns to be seen. Insolation has numerous aspects to it that each affects it in turn, which are divided into three categories of long term, short term and local. Quite possibly the most important aspect is latitude, a long term factor. The effect of latitude on the heat budget can be seen all over the globe, but the most striking examples are that the annual amount of insolation in the Arctic region, located 66° north of the equator, is 75 W/m2 however it is 275 W/m2 in Egypt, located 26° north of the equator. Latitude holds such a large effect on insolation because a variation in latitude means variations in the altitude of the sun. Altitude of the sun affects insolation because as the angle of the sun in the sky decreases and becomes more oblique, the land area to be heated up by the rays and the depth of atmosphere they must travel through increase. Therefore the amount of insolation lost through absorption, scattering and reflection increases....

Words: 2388 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Critically Evaluate the Factors Influencing the Global Heat Budget

...Critically Evaluate the factors influencing the Global Heat Budget (40 marks) The global heat budget, also known as the atmospheric heat budget, is the balance between the incoming insolation (solar radiation), and outgoing radiation from Earth. Due to absorption, reflection and scattering throughout the atmosphere, the Earth’s surface only receives 24% of the incoming insolation. Whilst the atmosphere has a net deficit of energy, the surface has a net gain, except for the polar regions. This difference therefore results in movement of energy from the surface to the atmosphere. Several factors affect the amount of insolation and thus the heating of the atmosphere, including latitude, seasons, diurnal range, altitude, ocean currents, cloud cover, human activity, aspect, specific heat capacity and distance from the ocean. Latitude, defined as the angular distance of a place north or south of the equator, is often considered  the main factor influencing the heat budget. As the latitude increases, the angle of the sun in the relative sky decreases, causing more insolation to be absorbed or reflected by the atmosphere. The curvature of the Earth results in the insolation spreading out over a larger surface area in more Northerly and Southerly latitudes than at the equator, thus lowering the amount of insolation per km2 at higher latitudes. NASA data indicates that areas around the equator absorbed around 200 W/m2 more on average than were reflected or radiated, whereas areas aroun...

Words: 2230 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Critically Evaluate Internal Analysis

...dynamic capabilities view. The resource based view There are several types of resources that a company possesses; physical resources, human resources, financial resources, intellectual capital, threshold resources, and unique resources. The RBV is based on the view that these resources are unique if they create sustained competitive advantage, and that a company’s strategy should be based on these resources. For a resource to be unique, it has to possess four attributes; it needs to be Valuable, it has to be Rare, it has to be impossible to Imitate, and there cannot be any substitutes. These four attributes can be remembered easily using the acronym VRIN. So what are valuable resources? Valuable resources contribute to the company’s effectiveness and efficiency. A rare resource is one controlled only by a few firms and is scarce in nature. An inimitable resource cannot be obtained by others because of unique historical conditions, casual ambiguity, and social complexity. The RBV is interesting since it tries to find the underlying causes for sustainable competitive advantage. The competence based view This view focuses on the distribution and use of resources and the processes that link them together. It is also about how to link knowledge and different activities together and how to best use your resources. Competencies are all about how you combine resources in order to achieve your goals. Not all competencies are essential to gain competitive advantage, but the ones......

Words: 1315 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Discuss and Critically Evaluate the Arguments Put Forward by the Specific Ingredients Perspective and the Common Factors Perspective, Regarding the Mechanism and Effectiveness of Counselling and Psychotherapy.

...Discuss and critically evaluate the arguments put forward by the specific ingredients perspective and the common factors perspective, regarding the mechanism and effectiveness of counselling and psychotherapy. Since its development during the 19th century more than three hundred and fifty distinct popular counselling and psychotherapy strands have emerged into the modern counselling field (Sparks, Duncan & Field, 2008). The years prior to psychotherapy’s birth were dominated by psychoanalytic and psychodynamic approaches and its practice was largely restricted to physicians (Miller, Hubble, Chow & Seidel, 2013). Psychotherapy’s arrival was not unnoticed from opposing schools of thought who were quick to question its scientific basis. Traditionally Eysenck (1952) not only challenged psychotherapy’s efficacy but also argued that it was “potentially harmful” (Miller, Hubble, Chow & Seidel, 2013:88). However, supporters of psychotherapy refuted Eysenck’s (1952) view and debate surrounding the fields worth began to accumulate. As a result psychotherapy research for the next few decades would focus on determining whether therapy was effective (House & Loewenthal, 2009). Subsequently, a plethora of studies that demonstrated its efficacy emerged (Smith Miller & Glass, 1980; Lambert & Bergin, 1994; Ahn & Wampold, 2001). So much so, that early studies revealed the treated population fared much better in comparison to their untreated counterparts (Sparks,......

Words: 4608 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

Outline and Critically Evaluate Research Into Out-of-Body Experiences

...Outline and critically evaluate research into out-of-body experiences (10 marks) An out-of-body experience, first defined by George Tyrell, is when a person appears to see his or her own body from above or outside themselves. This phenomenon has proven popular with psychologists who are trying to verify or falsify them however research is inconclusive. Miss Z was an American student who claimed to have out-of-body experiences during her sleep. Charles Tart arranged for Miss Z to spend four nights in a sleeping laboratory, during which time he would test to see whether her out-of-body experiences really occurred. In order to test it, Tart hid a random five-digit number in the sleeping lab each night and asked Miss Z to find and remember the number during her out-of-body experience. She managed to get the number correct every night – the probability of this being due to luck is 1/100,000 therefore Tart concluded that she must have had out-of-body experiences each night in order to get the number correct. Sceptics have since questioned the reliability and validity of the findings of Tart’s research. Miss Z moved away straight after the experiment, meaning it could not be replicated. The results therefore cannot be verified and compared to other results therefore they lack reliability. Tart (1969) did attempt a similar study using Robert Monroe who also claimed to have out-of-body experiences but the experiment was unsuccessful and the findings were never published. ...

Words: 529 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

A Comparative Analysis of the Effectiveness of Three Solvency Management Models

...A Comparative Analysis Of The Effectiveness Of Three Solvency Management Models By Enyi, Patrick Enyi Ph.D, MBA, B.Sc, ACA, ACCA, MFP, RFS. Fellow, American Academy of Financial Management (AAFM) Member, American Accounting Association (AAA) Head, Department of Accounting, Covenant University, Ota, Nigeria A Comparative Analysis Of The Effectiveness Of Three Solvency Management Models Abstract The introduction of the Altman’s Z-score model in 1983 and much recently the Enyi’s Relative Solvency Ratio model in 2005 has divergently provided financial analysts with alternative methods of analyzing corporate solvency which hitherto was exclusively done using the traditional historical record based ratio analysis, with particular reference to the current ratio. To test the relevance and effectiveness of the three models, real life performance data were extracted from the annual reports of 7 quoted companies, analyzed using the three models and the results compared to show the strengths and weaknesses of each. The result revealed that the current ratio and the Z-score models suffer from many limitations including imprecision while the Relative Solvency Ratio combines the capability of an effective indicator with the precision required of a true predictor. Keywords: Solvency, Liquidity, Ratio Analysis, Bankruptcy, Performance, Relative Solvency, Working Capital, Current Ratio, Current Assets, Balance Sheet 1. Introduction It is a proven fact over and......

Words: 6174 - Pages: 25

Free Essay

Explain and Critically Evaluate the Concept of “Freedom of Navigation”

...Topic: Explain and critically evaluate the concept of “freedom of navigation” Prepared by: Nadir Gürpınar Table of Content: 1. INTRODUCTION...........................................................................................................4 2. HISTORICAL ORIGIN OF THE FREEDOM OF NAVIGATION................................4 3. THE CONCEPT OF FREEDOM OF NAVIGATION.....................................................4 4. THE COASTAL STATE JURISDICTION....................................................................5 4.1. Internal Waters...........................................................................................................5 4.2. Territorial Seas...........................................................................................................6 4.3. Contiguous Zone........................................................................................................6 5. NAVIGATION IN TERRITORIAL SEA......................................................................6 5.1. Innocent Passage.....................................................................................................6 5.2. Straits.......................................................................................................................7 5.3. Transit Passage..................................................

Words: 2684 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Critically Evaluate the Potential Justification for Protectionism

...Critically evaluate the potential justification for protectionism Introduction A number of governments are concerned with unemployment and recessionary impact following the financial crisis. The result of this has been for many to be being placed under political pressure to implement protectionist instruments such as tariffs. quotas and subsidies (Love et al, 2014). This essay will identify the five principal instruments used by governments for protectionism and their consumer welfare implications. It will then seek to critically evaluate the justifications used for protectionism. Protectionist instruments and their welfare implications Protectionist instruments can be defined as a policy though which a government seeks to control international trade for the purpose of protecting local businesses or employment from foreign competition (Krugman et al, 2012). A Tariff is a tax which is levied on imported goods. Tariffs on goods increase their price in an economy and can be specific or ad velorum i.e. a proportion of the value of the good against which a tariff is raised. Tariffs impact on the welfare of market participants can be considered in the context of small countries (where foreign export prices cannot be affected) and large countries (where they can), the outcomes for which may be different. In small countries where tariffs are introduced, importing economies experience increases in imported goods and the price of substitutes manufactured locally, reducing......

Words: 1824 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Drawing on the Resource Based View Literature, Evaluate Whether and How Zara Generates Sustainable Competitive Advantage.

...literature, evaluate whether and how Zara generates sustainable competitive advantage. A firm is said to have competitive advantage when its profits exceed the average of its industry and that of its rivals (Grant, 1991). According to Grant (1991) the RBV sees organizations as a collection of resources which when combined forms organizational capabilities. The goal of every business strategy is to achieve a sustainable competitive advantage. According to Collis and Montgomery (2008) a firm’s resources are responsible for its better performance while working in a dynamic environment which academics term as resource based view of the firm (RBV). The RBV analysis assumes that both resources and capabilities are important for better performance and explains why some firms perform better than others in an industry. Using RBV as a framework this essay aims to examine how ZARA generates sustainable competitive advantage. (Opening is good, you have been able to introduce theory that would be discussed the essay). “A fast fashion system combines quick response production capabilities with enhanced product design capabilities to both design latest products that capture the latest consumer trends and exploit minimal production lead times to match supply with uncertain demand” (Cachon and Swinney, 2011). Fast fashion is widely gaining recognition as being a key enabler for success for modern fashion retailers (Barnes and Lea-Greenwood, 2006). Fashion retailers such as ZARA, H&M......

Words: 2205 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Critically Analyse the Effectiveness of Leadership in the Nhs

...HS 3001 LEADERSHIP AND CHANGE Critically analyse the effectiveness of leadership in the NHS Summary This essay will discuss and critically analyse the effectiveness of leadership role of senior nurses in the NHS. The essay will examine the definition of leadership, different theories of leaderships and how it can be implicated to nursing practice including changes that should be made to make nursing leaders more effective in NHS health care settings. Leadership is an important topic that is highly looked at in NHS. Policy makers approves that nurses have a leadership responsibility in clinical and managerial aspects of things in health care settings. Introduction There are so many different definition of leadership. According to Alimo-metcalfe and Lawler (2001) which stated ‘there is no single, robust definition of leadership available within UK organisations today’. Also according to Huber (2006) ‘leader use their power to bring teams together, spark innovation, create positive communication and drive forward toward group goals’ However, the most common definition that is used is by Northouse (2004), This defined leadership as ‘a process whereby an individual influences a group of individual to achieve a common goal’. This definition confines the fundamental nature of leadership but at the same time it has acknowledged that due to wild ranges of leadership perspective, there will be many definitions of what leadership means depending on the importance of......

Words: 1000 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Benetton Supply Chain

...Títol : Zara and Benetton: Comparison of two business models Volum: I de I Alumne:Amalia Paola Palladino Director/Ponent:Jose M. Cabré Garcia Departament:Organización de Empresas (OE) Data: 28 Junio 2010 Data:28 June 2010 DADES DEL PROJECTE Títol del Projecte: Zara and Benetton : Comparison of two business models Nom de l'estudiant:Amalia Paola Palladino Titulació:Ingenieria Superior Infomatica Crèdits:37,5 Director/Ponent: Jose M. Cabré Garcia Departament:Organizazión de empresas (OE) MEMBRES DEL TRIBUNAL President:Ferran Sabate Garriga,Toma de decisiones y gestión de proyectos empresariales(PDGPE) Vocal:Francesc Tiñena Salvañà, Compresion de datos e imagen (CDI) Secretari:Jose M. Cabré Garcia, Empresa y Entorno Economico (EEE) QUALIFICACIÓ Qualificació numèrica: Qualificació descriptiva: Data: AKNOWLEDGEMENTS First of all, I would like to thank Spanish professor Jose Cabré Garcia and Italian professor Massimo Visconti, my supervisors during the dissertation, for their helpfulness. Their academic and personal help was precious throughout this difficult task; Next, I would like to take this opportunity to thank the people who generously spent time to enable me to complete successfully my dissertation with the best possible result: - My family, who has supported me amazingly all these years, both financially and psychologically. Their love and support kept me going in difficult times. - My boyfriend Tomasz for his patience and moral support......

Words: 40581 - Pages: 163

Premium Essay

Zara

...Personal Website on Marketing Issues Sunday, December 28, 2008 Zara operation management, A business case! 1- Executive Summary Operations management is in regard to all operations within the organization related activities including managing purchases, inventory control, quality control, storage and logistics. A great deal of focus is on efficiency and effectiveness of such processes. An example of successful operations management in retail sector is obvious in Zara business model which is elaborated and discussed here by a team of MBA Strathclyde students. From one shop in La Coruña, the Zara empire has expanded to more 50 countries. While other giants in the business squeeze their profit margins by manufacturing in bulk and lowering prices, Zara understood that most of the customers are willing to pay for clothes if they feel they are getting exclusive and fashionable clothes. The company can design, manufacture and get a piece of clothing on the shelves in almost two weeks. This rapid supply chain allows Zara's copies to be in their stores before designers even have them in theirs. In summary, Zara has closed the loop from manufacturing to customers’ hands. They are obsessive about control. Mr. Ortega the CEO of the Inditex, the parent company of Zara, once said that the secret to retail success is to 'have five fingers touching the factory and five touching the customer'. 2 - Introduction Zara is the flagship brand of the Spanish retail group,......

Words: 3607 - Pages: 15