Premium Essay

Negligent Sterilization

In: Science

Submitted By hellmaster72
Words 693
Pages 3
Rene Descartes
March 24, 2014
Case Study

Case: Negligent Sterilization

1. I think I do agree with the court’s decision because Seslar had a very healthy baby. There was no harm done to the baby, the baby doesn’t have any kind of medical conditions. I think Seslar should be a little upset at the fact the she still had a baby even though she had surgery that was suppose to stop her from having children. After reading the case many times, now I get to the point where I don’t know if I agree with the court’s decision. I think it is kind of hard to make a decision because the doctor did not harm or hurt Seslar in any kind of way. I think that she may be emotionally hurt because she is having another child and may not be able to afford the expenses that come with it. But I think after having the surgery and still being able to have a healthy child, if it was me I wouldn’t go so hard on the doctor because even though she conceived a baby and she was not suppose to it’s still healthy. I also feel that she should just be happy with the outcome because the baby is not hurt, and there could have been many things that happen to the child but nothing happen and she should be happy with the outcome. The court can’t offer you money to help you raise a child, that’s her job even though she is not the reason the baby came.

2. I would not agree with the court when it comes to not rewarding money for educating and raising the child. The court doesn’t know if Seslar was mentally ready to have this baby. It could be really hard in her life right now, maybe that’s the reason she wanted to have a procedure to stop having children. The court doesn’t know her circumstances so maybe that’s the reason she decided to sue. I think that I would also choose to disagree with the court’s decision based on the amount of money it would take to raise a newborn child. I think that the people…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Torts Outline

...is one which a reasonable man would recognize as involving a risk of harm to another, the risk is unreasonable and the act is negligent if the RISK OUTWEIGHS THE UTILITY of the act or the way it’s done. Restatement § 292 Factors of utility: Social Value of the interest advanced or protected by the conduct Extent that the interest is advanced or protected by the conduct Extent or chance that it can be advanced or protected less dangerously. d) STANDARD OF CARE i) THE RPP Vaughan v. Menlove (Straw Fire) The issue at hand is not whether ∆ acted to the best of his judgment, but whether the prudent and reasonable man would have acted in a way that would prevent the fire. MENLOVE: If standard was accepted that a persons own best effort was enough(even if they are stupid)...... nobody would be liable because everybody would lie and say they tried their best.... Delair v. McAdoo (Tires) Negligence despite unknown risk The RPP would fix a bald tire. Risk is obvious regardless of professional or consumer. Trimarco v. Klein (Shower Glass) Knowledge of a customary safety practice creates a duty to adhere to practice. • Basically: If you know that everybody is doing something in the interest of safety, you have to pay somebody harmed by the avoidable danger. Cordas v. Peerless Transportation Co. (Diving Cabbie at Gunpoint) It’s totally okay to be negligent if it saves your life and isn’t a calculated effort to simultaneously harm others • Not a separate rule of negligence because......

Words: 13469 - Pages: 54

Premium Essay

Prevention and Control of Nosocomial Infections

...hospital environments. The work nosocomial literally means – of or relating to a hospital. Also known as hospital-acquired infections (or HAI) these occur in unsanitary or unclean hospital environments and can be contracted by hospital staff, hospital patients and visitors. Infections can be generally described as bacterial or fungal. Nosocomial infections will often cause urinary tract infections, and pneumonia among other things depending on the patient’s reaction to the infection. Many elements go into the cause and spread of nosocomial infections and, according to epidemiologic research, occur on an international level affecting people in the United States and abroad. Nosocomial infections may arise due to a lack of sterilization, improper or negligent procedures or simply accidental contraction. Prevention of nosocomial infection has steadily with the progress of modern medicine. Currently, there are specialists who examine the history, spread and prevention of nosocomial infections as it immediately affects the well-being of all parties involved and can be hazardous to the professional status of a facility. Prevention is the key to nosocomial infection in hospitals as it is oftentimes a result......

Words: 726 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Elements of Negligent Tort: Analysis and Remedies

...measure of success can be ensured in the outcome. Elements of Negligent Tort Negligence is the omission to do something, which a reasonable man, guided upon those considerations which regulate the conduct of human affairs would do or doing something, which a prudent, and reasonable, man would not do’ The essential elements of negligent tort are 1) Duty of reasonable care, 2) Breach of duty of care, 3) Breach was actual, and proximate cause of injury .Tort is what is in the tort books but only thing holding it together is their binding’, hence to win a negligence case, plaintiff must prove each of three elements. Duty of reasonable care: According to Negligence law, normally members of society should behave in ways that avoid the creation of unreasonable risks of harms to others. The standard for assessing such conduct is called µreasonable care standard and in most cases the duty to exercise reasonable care, serves as the relevant duty for the purpose of a negligence claim’s first element . Breach of duty: This is the second element of negligent tort, which requires plaintiff to establish that defendant failed to act as a reasonable person would have acted, thus negligent law’s focus on reasonableness of behavior and leads to a broad range of applications in everyday personal life, in business, and personal contexts. Actual and Proximate Cause: This is third element of a negligent tort, which is needed in the court to prove that the defendant’s......

Words: 1336 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Student

...is one which a reasonable man would recognize as involving a risk of harm to another, the risk is unreasonable and the act is negligent if the RISK OUTWEIGHS THE UTILITY of the act or the way it’s done. Restatement § 292 Factors of utility: Social Value of the interest advanced or protected by the conduct Extent that the interest is advanced or protected by the conduct Extent or chance that it can be advanced or protected less dangerously. d) STANDARD OF CARE i) THE RPP Vaughan v. Menlove (Straw Fire) The issue at hand is not whether ∆ acted to the best of his judgment, but whether the prudent and reasonable man would have acted in a way that would prevent the fire. MENLOVE: If standard was accepted that a persons own best effort was enough(even if they are stupid)...... nobody would be liable because everybody would lie and say they tried their best.... Delair v. McAdoo (Tires) Negligence despite unknown risk The RPP would fix a bald tire. Risk is obvious regardless of professional or consumer. Trimarco v. Klein (Shower Glass) Knowledge of a customary safety practice creates a duty to adhere to practice. • Basically: If you know that everybody is doing something in the interest of safety, you have to pay somebody harmed by the avoidable danger. Cordas v. Peerless Transportation Co. (Diving Cabbie at Gunpoint) It’s totally okay to be negligent if it saves your life and isn’t a calculated effort to simultaneously harm others • Not a separate rule of negligence because......

Words: 13469 - Pages: 54

Premium Essay

Negligent Tort

...by companies to any individuals because of the possible injury it might cause. The component on the tree connected to the electrical cord, the control box, can overheat and melt, posing burns and shock hazards. Only ten individuals have reported incidents with the remote control boxes and luckily no injuries were reported. It could have been much worse and injuries or accidents could have occurred and have gone much worse. With all previous lawsuits and liability issues that many companies have been issued in the past and are currently on the courts, companies have to be ready to be able to prevent these issues or be ready for any form of lawsuits. With all the information that has been presented, the company would be held liable and negligent if they would not perform a recall on the product presented in this case. Sometimes it has been presented that certain companies would be able to run a formula to see of not running a recall and just paying out certain amount of money would be more financially sound than running a recall on the product. Depending on the size of the company, certain companies will have a process set-up to determine the financial liability they will be held with of something happens, to pay out someone hurt or just recall the products. In this case, the company did show a duty of care for the individuals or customers purchasing its product. The company was trying to produce a top quality product that would help its sales in the Christmas product......

Words: 1457 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Sterilization

...process can lead to problems such as punctures or microinjuries in the film by sharp-edged products," says Daniel Ziebarth of the Südpack GmbH. "Sometimes there are products that have sharp or square edges that can damage the lower film if the wrong material was used." Ziebarth notes that companies have been reluctant to change their packaging to newer and better materials because they were afraid the re-qualification and validation effort. Development The development of new medical device products often takes several years to complete. Some companies make the mistake of not including in their early design process the aspects of packaging, sterilization, transportation, and storage. "If the product is developed without thinking about the packaging, there is already a failure," says Eric Schmohl. "If the product is made and I choose a sterilization method that is not compatible with the packaging or even the product, I create a lot of problems." The company now has to retrace its steps back to the product development process or redesign a product with a new packaging concept before it can be put on the market. Both possibilities can cost the company dearly. So MDMs should make sure to consider packaging early if they develop a new product. The Packaging System "From the sterile barrier to the packing box, the entire packaging system must be suitable for the product remains sterile," says Beate Klumpp, Director of Testing Services at mdt medical device testing GmbH. Klumpp says......

Words: 988 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Negligent Tort

...Negligent Tort Jacqulyné Allmon BUS 670: Legal Environment Instructor: Timory Naples June 24, 2013 Negligent torts are deemed unintentional which is one of the most common types of torts business managers experience and one of the most expensive. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) is charged with protecting the public from unreasonable risks of injury or death associated with the use of the thousands of consumer products under the agency's jurisdiction. Deaths, injuries, and property damage from consumer product incidents cost the nation more than $900 billion annually. In this essay a product will identified that has been subject to recall by using the Consumer Product Safety Division website www.cpsc.gov, determine whether if the product had not been recalled and had caused harm to a consumer, the manufacturer would be liable in negligence, and identify and discuss a relevant consumer protection statute identified under “Consumer Protection” in conjunction with the product recall was previously identified. Jeep Liberty Strollers were recalled on June 19, 2013 under recall number 13-221. Kolcraft, the manufacturer, and CPSC have received 39 reports of inner tube ruptures causing the wheel rim to fracture and fly off as a projectile. “Of these, 18 included reports of injury, with 14 occurring while filling the tire with air by an adult caregiver. Two children received lacerations to their chin or leg while standing near the stroller and 16 adults received......

Words: 1398 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Disney's Sterilization Aka Poison Candy

...Jonathan Sadie Homeira Foth ENGL 7 May 9th 2013 Disney’s “Sterilization” aka “Poison Candy” What would you say if Disney had something to do with you falling in love with your spouse? What about if Disney had something to do with all the relationships your have today? Most people would think this idea is absurd, yet it isn’t too far from the truth. We all grew up on Disney movies which poses the idea that these movies are a form of mass communication. The stories that where imprinted in our minds when our mind was more like sponges than an independent activist. Just like bed time stories that unleash children’s imagination before a night’s sleep will these same stories unleash a preconceived notion of action in real life. To have a favorite Disney movie is like having a favorite experience imbedded into our subconscious to tell us things such as what is “handsome” or “pretty”. Without noticing, many standards of today are set as we watch our first movie. So the big question is if Disney’s altered perspective of life is helping us live it. The proliferation of educational data that has been created regarding these seemingly innocent cartoon films provide a unique perspective that will influence what films we choose to show to our children. Disney’s sterilization process creates negative effects on children by painting an unrealistic picture, creating dependency issues, inhibiting a good coping system, and lacking confidence in the young. Disney’s interpretation of......

Words: 1511 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Negligent Hiring Practices

...Mandatory Background Checks Negligent Hiring Practices It is not uncommon for most businesses to enforce mandatory background checks upon hiring but how does that affect the individual who has been incarcerated or fired from a previous job? In this summary and critical analysis we will examine Lessing Gold and Chad Terhune differing opinions regarding the negligent hiring practices and lawsuits that stem from background checks. Lessing Gold holds the stance that mandatory background checks should be enforced with every employment, whereas Chad Terhune believes they should not due to inaccuracy of information. Very nice succinct summary in introduction of divergent points. Lessing Gold’s (year) entire argument was based on the idea that past criminal behavior should be accessible to the public due to safety concerns and without the information it puts potential customers and other employees at risk. Gold believes that every organization should require background check on employees whether the company position requires it or not. He gives an account of a customer that was kidnapped at gunpoint by an employee who had, in the past, been convicted of kidnapping. He argues that had the company implemented mandatory background checks and reviewed this information, it could have prevented this criminal from repeating past behaviors (Use book title here as how would one know what Bethel custom text was used. Bethel, 2011, p.376-377). Terhune (year) argues just the opposite.......

Words: 781 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Elements of a Negligent Tort

...Running head: Negligent Tort Elements The Elements of a Negligent Tort Arthur R. Scott Legal Environment: BUS670 Instructor: Dr. Lisa Barrow 28 August 2011 The Elements of a Negligent Tort A Tort is defined in our text as “a civil wrong that is not a breach of contract” and that it “contemplates civil liability for those who commit torts”. [ (Mallor, Barnes, Bowers, & Langvardt, 2010) ] A tort can be thought of as an action that occurs when an entity, a company or an individual(s) wrongfully injures another (socially, financially, or bodily) and damages are awarded as a result of litigation. One classification of tort civil wrongfulness is that of Negligence. Negligence as defined by our authors is “a failure to use reasonable care, with harm to another party occurring as a result”. The texts further expounds by saying negligence is characterized “as conduct that falls below the level reasonably necessary to protect others against significant risks of harm.” (Mallor, et al 2010) This paper will briefly discuss the elements of a negligent tort, which if successfully proven, can create a ligitimate negligent tort claim. The first element of a negligent tort is Duty. Duty, as defined by David G. Owen is simply “the obligation of one person to the other”. (Owen, 2007) Duty can be further explained as an extension of the reasonable behavior or care an individual would have for themselves to another individual or group in the same or similar situation. ......

Words: 1282 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Advnvijayaraj-Medicalnegligence

...will profess his skill with reasonable degree of care and caution. It should be taken in to consideration that the professional should command the “corpus of knowledge” of his profession. Since long the medical profession is highly respected, but today a decline in the standard of the medical profession can be attributed to increasing number of litigations against doctors for being negligent narrowing down to “medical negligence”. Public awareness on medical negligence in India is growing. Hospital managements are increasingly facing complaints regarding the facilities, standards of professional competence, and the appropriateness of their therapeutic and diagnostic methods. The health service has been under the purview of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 and subsequently the commercialization of the health sector has had adverse effects on doctor and patient relationship. The landmark case Indian Medical Association Vs. V.P.Shantha brought the medical professionals within the ambit of “service” as defined in the Consumer Protection Act, 1986. Many patients have filed legal cases against the negligent doctors and received compensation from them after establishing their negligence before the court of law. As a result, a number of legal decisions have been made on what constitutes negligence and what is required to prove it. It's a common observation that medical practitioners, hospitals are being attacked by family members of patient for alleged medical negligence. The......

Words: 6228 - Pages: 25

Free Essay

Ambalal

...serve  15  days'  rigorous imprisonment.  It  acquitted  the  other  accused.  Against  this  conviction  and  sentence  both  the accused filed separate appeals before the Addl. Sessions Judge, Baroda who acquitted them of the offences  with  which  they  were  charged.  The  State  of  Gujarat  appealed  against  the  acquittal  of both  these  accused.  The  High  Court  convicted  the  appellant  and  convicted  the  appellant  and sentenced him to 8 months' rigorous imprisonment as awarded by the trial Court but imposed no fine. The first accused was, however, acquitted. Against that Judgment this appeal is by certificate under Article 134(1)(c) of the Constitution. section 304a 304a not of standard quality 450 167 sterilization rash human life 165 amin 109 2. A few of the relevant facts as alleged by the prosecution are not really in dispute. S. C. I. Ltd. prepares  glucose  in  normal  saline,  a  solution  containing  dextrose,  distilled  water  and  sodium chloride  (popularly  known  as  common  salt).  It  appears  that  sodium  chloride  contains  certain quantities  of  lead  nitrate  but  according  to  the  American  Pharmacopoeia,  which  is  one  of  the Pharmacopoeias  recognised  by  the  Rules  under  the  Act  according  to  which  drugs  can  be manufactured,  lead  nitrate  of  5  parts  in  1  million  is  the  permissible  limit,  which  works  out ......

Words: 11324 - Pages: 46

Premium Essay

Eugenics and Beneficence

...Eugenics and Beneficence Eugenics and Beneficence On October 27, 2014, the North Carolina state legislature became the first in the country to officially begin compensating citizens and their families who were subjected the state’s forced sterilization program. Ninety years after the legalization of forced sterilization in the United States and forty-one years after the first lawsuit was brought by sterilized North Carolinian Nial Ramirez, it would seem as though the country is now ready to do penance in financial terms for its past actions via reparations to Mrs. Ramirez and others. (Burns, 2014) The purpose of this paper is to examine the concept of eugenics, specifically to view it through lens of beneficence, to try and view the issue from the points of view of all involved, and finally to explore some future implications about the nature of beneficence from this episode in the history of American health-care. Eugenics is the study of ways to influence (usually to improve) a population by selective breeding. ("Mosby’s Dictionary," 2009) The idea of influencing the quality of animal populations has existed since the beginning of domestication by humans, but the idea of subjecting the human race to systematic selective breeding is a more recent phenomenon. Western thought about the nature of living creatures until the 19th century had been shaped by Judeo-Christian traditions in which a creator god made and sustained all the diversity of life, and further had......

Words: 1951 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Eugenics

...societies. This embraces the notion that human societies can evolve into “superior” forms. These Governments targeted marginalized groups and applied the principles of racial hygiene using forced sterilization, and genocide. Even though Canada and Germany used different over arching strategies, but their main objective was to determine who is fit to be apart of the nation. Similarities During the 1930’s eugenics benign form promoted healthy living and “social purity”. However in its tyrannical form, the program-sought ways to ensure “fit” members of society that portrayed undesirable elements were bred out of the population. In most countries where eugenics beliefs were enshrined in legislation, efforts were made to limit reproduction among “unfit” groups through public education, institutionalization and forced sterilization. While Nazi Germany, eugenics beliefs woven into nationalism led to the forced sterilization thousands. They created concentration camps for Jewish and the “Lebensborn” program in which young German women with classic Nordic features forced to mate with members of Hitler’s elite SS troops. Eugenics Movement in Canada and Germany: The popularity of eugenics at the time led to the development of legislation that authorized involuntary sterilization by both Canadian and German governments. Politicians and social elites tried to accelerate the progress of the nation by harnessing the power of science. However these progressive goals were......

Words: 1439 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Negligent Tort Paper

...Negligent Tort Paper: Black Diamond Climbing Ascenders Recall The Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) has been given the power to seek court injunctions against companies to keep unsafe products from being marketed and to urge companies to remove hazardous products (Pittle, 1976). To avoid negligent torts many companies will do recalls of bad products to remedy whatever the problem may be. Xia Liu, Yong & Ting (2016) states a product recall consists of a replacing or compensating consumers for defective products. Black Diamond Equipment Ltd is an importing and distribution company based out of Salt Lake City Utah. On May 19, 2016, the Black Diamond recalled Index Ascenders for climbing, including manufacturing codes from 4356 to 6015, because of a defect of the Index Ascender’s rivet holding the toothed cam releasing allowing the Ascender to slide on the rope or coming detached from the rope leading to possible injuries or death as a result of falling (U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission). The recall was for both the right and left versions of the Black Diamond brand Index Ascenders, which are used as rope clamps for rock climbing and mountaineering to prevent falls. There were no reported injuries or deaths but there was a recall on the products urging consumers to stop use of the product and to return it for a free replacement. According to Seaquist (2012), in general most reasonably prudent people abide by laws put in place that impose a duty to not inflict......

Words: 2038 - Pages: 9