Premium Essay

Should the Australian Government Provide Money to Car Manufacturers to Stop Them from Moving Overseas?

In: Business and Management

Submitted By lucarizzello
Words 880
Pages 4
Should the Australian Government provide money to car manufacturers to prevent them from moving their operations overseas? Discuss, drawing on contemporary debates about this issue in the news media?
The Australian Government should provide money to car manufacturers to prevent them moving their operations overseas. The car manufacturing industry provides jobs to many Australians and by moving operations overseas many Australians will lose their jobs. Due to the recent overseas relocation of Ford and Toyota there has been a “loss of.. 50,000 jobs” (Martin, Feb 12th 2014, SMH). By losing their jobs, Australian workers are being left stranded without an income and the inability to work in the industry they have been trained in for most of their careers. By the government giving million dollar packages to major car manufacturing companies such as Holden, they are giving employees payouts to assist them after they leave the company. Also by giving companies huge subsidies, they are trying to help them not to move their operations offshore into foreign countries.
However by giving car manufacturing companies such as Holden and Toyota huge payouts, the common Australian taxpayer is left to fit the bill. Many critics of the Australian government’s huge subsidies are questioning whether it is worth pouring millions of dollars into an industry which is closing down operations in Australia by 2017. David Sinclair, a Professor of Economics at RMIT said that “you can’t just really buy Australian jobs by tipping corporate welfare into corporations; we actually need to have viable businesses that can survive without that sort of corporate welfare” (Sinclair, May 23rd 2013, ABC). By assisting car companies with subsidies, they are solving a short term problem and not thinking about the long term future of the company and its employees.
The Australian Government shouldn’t be…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Should the U.S Provide Foreign Aid to Syria?

...Should the U.S provide foreign aid to Syria? Syria continues to be categorized as a state sponsor of terrorism, since 1979. Syria’s government supports U.S.-listed terrorist groups and allows some of these groups, such as Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad, to maintain headquarters in Damascus. Both of these organizations have been labeled as a terrorist group not only by the U.S, but also by the European Union, the United Kingdom, Japan, Canada, and Israel. The Syrian government also houses and aids worldwide terrorists, and serves as the center of trade in illegal narcotics. An American supported Israeli-Syrian treaty would make it far more difficult, rather than easier, for the United States to speak up or take action against these activities. The 2006 State Department Country Report says the Syrian government remains an active supporter of Hezbollah and has a secret presence in Lebanese politics. The goal of the Hezbollah is to dominate Lebanese politics in order to create a theocratic Islamic state out of Iran and to act as Iran’s (and Syria’s) substitute in confronting Israel and the US as a second front. Syria has suspected ties to the assassination of former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri in 2005. However, Syria still rejects the terrorist categorization, denies involvement in the Hariri killing, and says it was Hamas, Hezbollah, and other groups on its soil to be legitimate resistance movements aimed at beneficial Arab territory held by Israel. Reports claim...

Words: 1847 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Moving Headquarters Overseas

...Moving headquarters overseas has been a growing trend since the 1990s as more and more countries become open to the idea of relocation. In our case, we saw examples of big multi-national companies moving headquarters across continents, like Nokia moving from Finland to the United States, IBM from the United States to China and HSBC from London to Hong Kong. This report will examine the reason behind this phenomenon and what are the consequences as a result of that. There are some key reasons that lead to this trend. i) Moving closer to the Asian market As Asia continues to charge ahead in its development, many companies want to fight for a slice of the pie and are moving into Asia to take advantage of the growing demand there. For example, Procter & Gamble (P&G) has this year moved its global headquarters for their beauty and baby-care business, including its biggest brand, Pampers, from Cincinnati to Singapore. They have expressed that the move to Singapore was motivated by a need for P&G brands to be closer to the growing number of consumers in Asia. As we can see from this, multi-national companies see the importance of the Asian market and believe that in order to take advantage of the potential there, need to relocate their headquarters. It is no longer enough to just have operations in Asia, but it is also helpful to have headquarters within the region to facilitate development. ii) Moving away from heavy corporate taxes The next trend is that of...

Words: 1805 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Should the Government Provide Healthcare?

...dollars. Therefore, I believe the government should provide health care to all citizens regardless of their ability to pay for that care. Some rich people may prefer to pay for medical treatment, while the government must necessarily subsidize the health care for children, senior citizens, the unemployed and the homeless, as these groups cannot provide for themselves and, are extremely financially vulnerable. However, working adults can use the benefits of the medical insurance, which will give them an opportunity for a decent medical service and reduce the general taxation burden. The issue of health care throughout the years has been a major issue in the society in the United States and it is one of the most important aspects of an election campaign of any political party. One issue concerning healthcare is that it is very expensive and more than 52 million people do not have any coverage or they have less adequate coverage. In addition, it is very important for people to have coverage for general healthcare maintenance and just in case, something drastic occurs, in their life. A well-organized, efficient health care system is not that easy to provide and one of the key problems on the way to the ideal hospitals and medical help is proper funding. Nowadays, there are three basic types of funding: private, insurance and state. Nevertheless, many people believe that the government must bear full responsibility for providing the money our health care service needs.......

Words: 311 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Should Government Be Responsible for Csr?

...Should Government have the largest influence on Corporate Social Responsibility ? Introduction Carroll’s four responsibilities of business are economic, legal, ethical, and discretionary (Carroll, 1991). Economic responsibility is a business organization to produce goods or service to society, and creditors or shareholders can get return. Legal responsibility is defined in law by government that management is expected to follow. Ethical responsibility is organization management to obey the beliefs in a society. The last discretionary responsibility is the management of their own accord to take obligations, they do it by themselves, and not others force them to do (Carroll, 1991). Definition of Corporate Social Responsibility Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) is defined as a business’s decisions or actions are made which take outcomes beyond the organization's economic profit into account in the decision making process (Carroll, 1991). Social responsibilities include ethical responsibilities and discretionary responsibilities. The difference between them was that less people expect a firm to perform discretionary responsibilities, while a lot of people expect a firm to perform ethical responsibilities. Discretionary responsibilities are like day-care centers, to training the hard-core unemployed and philanthropic contributions. A firm can take actions to perform its ethical responsibilities and discretionary responsibilities that society will value it......

Words: 2304 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Why the Government Should Subsidize Hybrid Cars

...Why the Government Should Subsidize Hybrid Cars In the midst of an economic recovery and an energy crisis, the United States of America is at the brink of much political debate. One major political dispute arises as to whether or not hybrid cars should be subsidized. According to our research, the economy would be more sustainable and prosperous if the government subsidized the purchase of and research and development of hybrid vehicles. The sales of hybrid cars have steadily declined by 53% within the past year, which is rather detrimental to society. Incentives to buy hybrid cars are too insignificant because technology has not yet been able to produce them at affordable prices. Subsidies should be provided because positive externalities are not accurately reflected in the cost. America desperately needs to create solid energy policies in order to thrive domestically and internationally. With an inadequate amount of attention directed towards environmental and energy issues, America should embrace hybrid vehicles in order to reduce our consumption of foreign oil, thwart the threat of global warming, and implement innovative techniques to use energy more efficiently. To support our findings, we will explore the negative externalities associated with a petroleum-based economy and emphasize the magnitude of environmental benefits that could be reached with more hybrid vehicles. Further we will use economic analysis to justify that the implementation of these......

Words: 690 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Australian Federal System’s Effect on Australian Businesses

...The Australian Federal System’s effect on Australian businesses It is widely thought that the role of the government is to guide their economy into a steady growth and provide support for their local industries and businesses. However there is a growing dispute with that statement with recent media coverage of large iconic Australian companies such as Qantas and Holden in dire economic situations. This paper will argue that the role of the Australian government is to stimulate the national economy and to help Australian businesses. However these aides must be beneficial to both the government and the business. If the assistance is non-sustainable, then the government is not obliged to try and alter the inevitable. In order to support this argument, this paper will provide an understanding of Australia’s social structure and analyse the companies listed above In order to understand the role of the Australian government on businesses is to understand how Australia was built. The doctrine of separation of power was inherited with the birth of the Federation of Australia in 1901. The doctrine split the institutions of government into three branches; legislative, executive and judicial. This is a way to prevent a corruption, internal abuse of power and conflict of interest of people in high positions of the government. Although there are numerous interpretations of ‘Capitalism in Australia’, Lloyd (2008, p.30) states that “From 1992 Australia has experienced a period of......

Words: 1080 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Australian Mobile Telecommunications Association

...Australian Mobile Telecommunications Association Annual Report 2013 AMTA Contacts Membership For information about AMTA or membership inquiries phone (02) 6239 6555 or see the website: MobileMuster To contact MobileMuster phone 1300 730 070 or email For more information about MobileMuster go to Mobile Carriers Forum To contact the Mobile Carriers Forum phone (02) 6295 8191 or see the website: AMTA Members Carriage Service Providers Dodo Australia, Lebara Mobile, Lycamobile, Optus, Telstra, VHA Pty Ltd AMTA Vision The Australian Mobile Telecommunications Association is the peak national body representing Australia’s mobile telecommunications industry. AMTA’s vision is to promote an environmentally, socially and economically responsible, successful and sustainable mobile telecommunications industry in Australia. AMTA aims to achieve its vision by: ■ effective industry representation and leadership ■ generating consensus on whole-of-industry issues ■ improving the level of trust between the industry, related industries, key stakeholders and the wider community ■ promoting an improved understanding of the mobile telecommunications industry and its contribution to the Australian community. Handset Manufacturers LG Electronics Australia, HTC ( Aust & NZ), Nokia Australia, Motorola Mobility Australia, Research in Motion, Samsung Australia, Sony Ericsson, ZTE Australia ...

Words: 11552 - Pages: 47

Premium Essay

Government Should Give Subsidies Manufacturesto

...In this essay am going to agree that the government should give subsides to car manufactures. In recent days there is a lot happening regarding car manufacturing industries.We see business being taken over by other shareholders overseas and the common news which we hear every day that is cutting jobs. If the government does not provide the automotive industry with enough assistance, the companies will easily go to liquidation. In my opinion this stops the outside people from taking over and jobs being lost. However, it is good for business too when an overseas individual or a firm occupies the business in the country. According to economics outside business can boost the business of the whole nation. The prime minister does not intend in any way to assist car industry which is good and bad. Looking at it, we see quiet a lot of outside investors chipping in when a company is broke. This however does not look good especially a first world country like Australia. The Productivity Commission has rejected calls for extra federal assistance for Toyota's car-manufacturing operations and called for all Australian government subsidies to carmakers to end by 2020(Maher, 2014).This indicates that by 2020 Toyota will be no more and it means jobs are going to be lost too. Mercury, 2014, said that by 2017,2500 jobs would be cut, and Toyota will quit doing business with Australia. It is reported that Toyota has hold talks with some foreign investors who are willing to take over the......

Words: 321 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Car Industry Economy

...Should the Australian Government provide money to car manufacturers to prevent them from moving their operations overseas? Discuss, drawing on contemporary debates about this issue in the news media. Introduction Car manufacturing in Australia was one of the strongest sector in the Australian economy. Within the past few months and ongoing weeks, there are several news being published that the Australian car manufacturing sector has become so small that that each car company is relying on the survival of the other. In relation to the debates and media news, this essay demonstrates, as to whether the Government should provide funds to car manufactures to prevent them operating overseas. The news has been all over the place that the three main car manufacturers, Toyota, Holden and Ford are expected to shut down their operations in Australia in the coming Years. The local content of the Australian made cars is in decline. According to figures supplied by the car makers, 30% of the parts to make Holden Cruise was sourced locally and 50% was Commodore. To survive beyond current models, car manufactures were going to be forced to rely more on foreign parts to keep the costs down. Due to low sales and low cost sales, the three manufactures are shutting down to recover from the massive financial losses and start making a profit. The data illustrates that the three factories have lost more than 1.5 billion dollars on their local manufacturing operations over the past decade...

Words: 786 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Should the Australian Government Privatise Medibank Private?

...Should the Australian Government privatise Medibank Private? Since the 1990s the Commonwealth and State governments of Australia has privatised a sizeable portion of the public sector (Reserve Bank of Australia 1997). The prospect of privatising Medibank has been a controversial matter since its proposal by the Howard government in 2006, although the former government failed to do so, the Abott government announced on March 26th, 2014 that the company will be sold off through an initial public offering (IPO) in the 2014-15 financial year (Mcllroy 2014). This essay will argue that Medibank Private should be privatised and sold publicly through an IPO for short and long term economic and social benefits. In order to determine the validity of this argument this essay will analyse articles and other academic evidences to first look into Australia’s history of privatisation and a brief history of Medibank Private. The essay will then analyse the conflict of interest the current system generates. Further, it will explore the advantage of privatising Medibank Private, including increasing competitiveness in the market and money generated for other social and economic projects. The Reserve Bank of Australia (1997:7) defines privatisation as the full or partial transfer of ownership of public assets to the private sector (Reserve Bank of Australia 1997). Privatisation gradually increased across the world in the 1980’s originating in Chile, the UK and New Zealand which was...

Words: 1872 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Hyundai Car Manufacturer the future? Brief Summary Hyundai immerged as one of the fast-growing and aggressive Car manufcturing Company in the world with a strategy of BenchMarketing, high incentives to the customers, quality enhacement and aggressive product developing. Hyundai, established in 1967, get high places in several surveys such as J.D. power’s products’ qulity after 30 days and also 3 years. Its speed of operations and boldness of decision making is considered as a reason of this drastic vault. And we don’t know for sure how this improvement could go because Hyundai faces many opportunity such as, promotion of ’Equus’ , lowered possibility of labor stoppage and many risks such as yet not much great brand image, and possibilty of mistake comes out of too much speedy decision making. Success Factors 1. Rapidness in monitoring, decision making and execution Along with throughful monitoring of company’s operations in company, Hyunda can capture and track the problem easily whereas other companys focus on innovation or consistency. That could be the way that Hyundai can handle the large company that has grown up in short life span. This rapid growthe can also be explained with speedy decision making process in Hyundai. Krafcik, who recently as a member of other auto moblie company, says that there are fewer people who participate in Hyundai’s decision making, so it doesn’t suffer from bureaucrats. Last but not least Hyundai’s speed also is shown in manufacturing. They are......

Words: 708 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Cyber Attacks What Should America Do to Stop Them

...Cyberattacks: What Should America Do To Stop Them? Eric Gilliam Colorado Technical University Cyberattacks: What Should America Do To Stop Them? In the past few years, Cyberattacks have increased more than any cyber expert could have expected. Hackers and nation state sponsored attacks have risen about forty eight percent in 2014. America needs to do something now, before it gets worse. If we do not find a way to put a stop to these Cyberattacks hacker could essentially destroy our financial infrastructure. If this was to happen there would be no plastic to use for payment. Cyberattacks are here to stay. We need the help from ethical hackers to police the Cyberattacks world. When you watch the news, you hear about Cyberattacks on a daily basis. What you probably did not realize is “Cyberattacks cost business about 2.7 Million dollars per business” (White, 2014) per business. Cyberattacks are increasing and it is something we all need to look at. When this article came out, there were about 117,339 Cyberattacks every day. Now Cybercriminals are targeting mid-range businesses because larger businesses have increased their security. Cyberattacks can take down anything hackers want to destroy. “The UK National Security Strategy says that there is real risk. Attacks in cyberspace can have a potentially devastating real-world effect. Government, military, industrial and economic targets, including critical services” (Ncube, 2016), for example, hospitals or......

Words: 516 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Should the Federal Government Provide Healthcare for Citizens That Cannot Afford Their Own?

...The Federal Government should provide health care for citizens who cannot afford it. Actually the Government should provide health care for all citizens and legal residents, whether they can afford it or not. Healthcare should be a right; everyone should be entitled to proper healthcare and not be subject to being medically treated or not, based on their financial status. Because of the economic downturn, there is a much higher percentage of citizens that cannot afford to pay for healthcare. Here in the United States the healthcare system is quite complicated; it is operated under a managed care system. There are many people today that are hard working honest citizens that cannot even afford to pay for the healthcare insurance even if it is offered at their job. There are quite a few countries in the world that provide healthcare for all citizens including the United Kingdom and Canada. Right here in the United States the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Healthcare reform is set up to provide healthcare for those who cannot afford, why can’t it be done nationwide. The new health Reform or ‘Obama care’ as it is becoming popularly known as, is designed to assist those who cannot afford proper healthcare. In my opinion, every citizen or non citizen of a country should be entitled to proper healthcare. Healthcare should be a right and not judged on how much income you have. There are people in this country that have not been treated properly because they do not have any health......

Words: 1249 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

A Particular Car Manufacturer

...and Marketing: Should have Knowledge of principles and methods for showing, promoting, and selling products or services. This includes marketing strategy and tactics, product demonstration, sales techniques, and sales control systems. Customer and Personal Service: Knowledge for providing customer and personal services. This includes customer needs assessment, meeting quality standards for services for customer satisfaction. English Language: Knowledge of the structure and content of the English language including the meaning and spelling of words, rules of composition, and grammar. Active Listening: Giving full attention to what other people are saying, taking time to understand the points being made, asking questions as appropriate, and not interrupting at inappropriate times. Persuasion: Persuading others to change their minds or behaviour. Speaking: Talking to others to convey information effectively. Service Orientation: Actively looking for ways to help people. Negotiation: Bringing others together and trying to reconcile differences. Communication Skills: Should have great communication skills in order to communicate well with customers. Physical Requirements: Ability to maintain good, punctual attendance Must be presentable to the customers to give them good vibe Must not get tired so easily Should be quick not slow Should have the ability to do all kinds of work as in stretching, lifting, standing, sitting, kneeling & bending Should handle and......

Words: 1193 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Should Government Provide Health Care to Its Citizens?

...speech thing Chris D Does government have a responsibility to provide health care for its citizens? Well they are two sides to it both sides thoroughly argued and researched. America itself is the only “westernized” country without any universal healthcare, along with Africa (exception of South Africa) India, the Philippians and others. While many argue that America is in need of a health care system, many of its recipients (not all) are unemployed and blew their chances at school. But also many are poor and can’t afford necessary health care especially in our current economy. It is essential for those who cannot take care of themselves to receive the proper care to maintain a healthy and happy life. The Declaration of Independence states there are certain 'inalienable rights', including life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. If Americans believe in an inalienable right to life, how can we tolerate a system that denies people lifesaving medications and treatments? Not only that, The Preamble to the United States Constitution and Article One of the U.S. Constitution both describe an originating purpose of our United States: to promote the general welfare. Health care is a legitimate function of our government. Even in countries like Canada and the U.K., there is no right to health care. Rather, citizens in these countries are told by government what health-care treatments they are eligible to receive and when they can receive them. Although Canada has a......

Words: 334 - Pages: 2