Free Essay

Wendy's Chili Finger Case

In: Historical Events

Submitted By phatle07
Words 1216
Pages 5
Case: Wendy’s and the Finger-in-the-Chili

In March 2005, Anna Ayala, a Las Vegas resident visiting San Jose, California, went to Wendy’s with her family. She ordered a bowl of Beef Chili. She said she bit into a spoon of chili and “suddenly I chewed something that’s kind of hard, crunch. I spit it out.” She said that’s when she realized the crunchy item was a 1 and half inch human finger well manicured nail. She hired a lawyer and sued.
Denny Lynch, Senior VP of communication for Wendy’s international faced a crisis that innocent food based companies fear. When a customer commits a vicious act that cost other’s to turn away from the restaurant, or product. Lynch received a call that night from Bob Bertini, Wendy’s director of Communications, explaining what happened. Lynch had to act immediately. Lynch and Bertini constantly dealt with the media for the next 60 days.
At first Santa Clara county health dept. had sympathy for Ms. Ayala and said she was ill and distraught so emotionally upset causing her to vomit. The Health Dept. released photos of the finger to media. The national news coverage intensified. The health dept. stated that there was no public health risk.

Wendy’s then needed to place a plan into action, First Wendy’s regional management team set up a makeshift control room in a franchise office in San Jose, and the police were involved, as was the coroner.

Wendy’s crisis management strategy centered on four areas:

1. Conducting due diligence to establish the brand was not at fault. 2. Ensuring the Wendy’s key company values drove all decisions and activities. 3. Briefing and mobilizing team members for quick action and response as events unfolded. 4. Building a post-incident campaign that enhanced Wendy’s brand.
The Initial Effects
Initially, county health officials said Ayala was fine and the finger had been cooked, which would have killed any bacteria in the finger. However, on March 27, officials admitted they were not so sure anymore. Tests were done on the finger to determine this. Dr. Fenstersheib, Santa Clara County's health officer, said that even if the finger was still raw when Ayala bit into it, the risk was low that she would have become infected with anything. However, he advised that Ayala should undergo a series of precautionary follow-up tests.
Sales at Wendy's went down because of the incident.
April 5th, officials had still not succeeded in tracking down the owner of the finger. The fingerprint on the detached digit has been run through an FBI database as well as the local criminal database in Santa Clara County, but no matches were found.
The Investigation
The next day, on Wednesday the 6th, Las Vegas police searched the home of Anna Ayala. About a dozen officers conducted the search at Ayala's home at Maryland Parkway and Serene Street at about 4 p.m, according to witnesses at the scene. Ayala and other residents were handcuffed and brought out of the house. San Jose, police spokeswoman Gina Tepoorten confirmed to reporters that investigators had served the warrant in cooperation with Las Vegas police on Wednesday, but she refused to reveal specific details about the warrant. Wendy's was offering a $50,000 reward for information leading to the source of the finger.

Research by the Associated Press uncovered Ayala's history of lawsuits. Ayala successfully won her suit for medical expenses against the national El Pollo Loco chicken-chain, a previous employer, after her daughter Genesis contracted salmonella poisoning, allegedly from eating at the restaurant. However, Ayala lost another suit against General Motors in 2000 claiming that a wheel fell off her car. She also started a sexual harassment suit against her former boss in 1998. A total of 13 lawsuits in California and Nevada had been filed. Ayala replied the focus should be on Wendy's, and not her record of law suits. Nick Muyo, a spokesman for the San Jose Police department, said not to expect new information in the case for at least a week.

The Twist
On Wednesday the 13th there was a potential new lead in the investigation. A spotted leopard had torn off part of a finger from an owner of exotic animals, Sandy Allman, in Pahrump, Nevada. The portion of Allman's torn off finger was approximately the same size - 1 1/2-inches long. Pahrump is approximately 45 miles away from Las Vegas. Carol Asvestas, who owns an exotic animal sanctuary, told the San Jose Mercury News she witnessed the leopard tear off the finger. She reported the incident to a hotline run by Wendy's offering the $50,000 reward. Cindy Carroccio told the San Jose Mercury News that the finger was not reattached, and that the clinic "gave it back to her (Allman) in a little bag of ice." On the same day the lead was announced, Ayala decided to drop her lawsuit against Wendy's, due to emotional stress. Prints were later sent off and the finger did not match the prints for Allman, leaving the new lead to a hault.

The Arrest
On Thursday the 21st of April, Anna Ayala was arrested at or near her home in Las Vegas on Thursday evening, in connection with the case, shortly after Wendy's finished its own internal investigation. According to court documents, she has been charged with one count of attempted grand larceny related to the chili case, and one count of grand larceny in an unrelated real estate deal, and is being held without bail in Clark County, Nevada, pending extradition. A press conference by the San Jose Police and Wendy's was held on Friday, April 22, The charge related to the case states the finger could not have been prepared at Wendy's, where the chili is heated to 170 degrees for 3 hours. There is also an inconsistency in Ayala's account of finding the finger and claiming it caused her to vomit compared with police saying there was no vomit at the scene. The incident has caused Wendy's 2.5 million dollars worth of damages, which Ayala could be criminally responsible for. Until recently, the San Jose police had not accused Ayala of planting the finger herself.

The unrelated charge stems from an incident, also in San Jose, when Ayala allegedly received an $11,000 down payment on a mobile home she did not own.

Ayala was incarcerated at the Clark County Detention Center, awaiting a fugitive review hearing on Tuesday, April 26, 2005, She was processed. Ayala waived extradition at the hearing, and her attorney said they were ready to come to San Jose to defend against the charges. On September 9, 2005, Ayala plead guilty to conspiring to file a false claim and attempted grand theft, and will be sentenced on November 2, 2005. She faces up to ten years in prison, and her husband faces up to 13 years behind bars.

Finger's owner identified
The owner of the finger still had not been found. But on May 13, 2005, police announced that they had identified the finger tip as belonging to an associate of Ayala's husband. The associate had lost his finger tip in an industrial accident at an asphalt company in December, 2004. Police had received the information from an undisclosed caller to Wendy's hot-line.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Accounting Chili

...222 ( Kelvin ) WENDY’S CHILLI 1. The cost of ground beef is a joint cost. The ground beef is made into beef patties which are used first for hamburger. However, the “well-done” beef patties that cannot be served as “hot ‘n juicy” old-fashioned hamburgers will be used to make chili. At this point, the ground beef patties used for hamburgers and the ground beef patties used to chili split off and become separately identifiable. 2. Hamburgers account for 55% of Wendy’s total sale, while chili only composes for 5%. Therefore, chili is a by-product of hamburger. The meat that goes into making chili is a by-product of hamburgers. The over-cooked meat is used as input in the process of making chili instead of being thrown away. It enables Wendy to avoid incurring extra costs. 3. Option 1: The cost of chili does not vary with the seasons. During the month of October through March, 60% of annual chili sale occurred. It happened approximately 10% of the time; it became necessary to cook meat specifically for use in making chili. However, the price of ground beef does not change. Even though the total cost of making chili increases, the unit cost remains unchanged. There is no need to increase the price as well. Option 2: : The cost of chili does vary with the seasons. During the month of October through March, 60% of annual chili sale occurred. It happened approximately 10% of the time; it became necessary to cook meat specifically for use in making chili, which......

Words: 493 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Wendy's International Case Study

...Read the description on page 57 of the book,"Wendy's International Relies on Text Mining for CEM," and answer the. Select one side of the argument as described and provide convincing points either in favor or against the proposal that an investment in text message collection and mining should be made even if no clear positive ROI (return on investment) from better execution can be determined in advance. A healthy customer relationship plays a crucial part in the success of a business. In today's competitive marketplace, every organization wants to know whether its customers are satisfied with the company services or not and their views about the products and services. These all things can be done with a customer survey. Companies can get many benefits by surveying their customers. It is really an inexpensive way to get customer feedback which can help the company to improve customer retention, and customers' suggestion or their creative ideas can help to improve company's product or may help to launch a new product. A company can survey its customers by several ways including text messaging,web-based feedback forms, social media, e-mail messages, call center notes and receipt-based surveys. Nowadays scenario has been changed. People are always on move, you are not able to see them sitting all the time in front of the computer. But most of all the people keep their mobile with them 24 hours a day. So when the company sends its customers survey questions through text......

Words: 1055 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Wendy's Training

...Wendy’s is one the world largest restaurant franchisement in operation, with a workforce of over 227,000 employees and a turnover rate of 180%-200% annually, about 50% of the workforce worldwide needs to be trained on the procedures & culture of the quick service franchisement. Wendy’s has a very complex technological system at each branch & with the duty of having to train five mangers per store, there is a desperate need to have a easy & convenient training program to achieve this. Jeff Kent, Wendy’s vice president of solution delivery, said that “training & development is very key part of providing our customers with a consistent experience in every restaurant regardless of store locations.” In order to achieve this they need a system that could implement a training & development solution that agrees with the franchise standards, evaluate test results before & after to monitor the effectiveness of the program as well as adapt to its ever-changing workforce. A system which turns away from their disparate legacy paper based training system which was highly unreliable & it was difficult to track whether the training was given effectively & which employee or manager stood fit to do the job. Wendy’s search criteria for such a system included, improvement to the consistency of company’s training program at all locations, providing just-in-time training & reducing the time it takes to get a class in the field. Overall the program needed to......

Words: 630 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Wendy's and Jollibee

...Business Management CHALLENGING THE GLOBAL LEADER: LESSONS FROM WENDY’S AND JOLLIBEE INTRODUCTION Competition in fast-food industry is intensely grow, thus globalization is carefully observed along with its unique innovation in order to attract potential consumers. Fast-food chains generally offered wide array of products from simple refreshments to full meals. In the Philippines, Jollibee and McDonald’s are the two industry leaders which is primarily been at the forefront as the new entrants established their foundation while existing fast-food chain players continued their battle for market share (Figure 1). WENDY’S In 1969, Wendy’s was founded by R. David Thomas in Columbus, Ohio and was considered one of the leading fast-food chains in the world. At Wendy’s inception, the brand represented Wendy’s competitive advantages in the marketplace for being known for its innovation to their menus such as the Salad Bar, Hot-Stuffed Baked Potatoes and the whole breast Chicken Sandwiches aside from its great tasting hamburger. Wendy's set an industry practice by offering old fashioned and made to order hamburgers using fresh meat. “To become bigger than McDonald’s” but not “another McDonald’s” was the goal of Thomas that also serves as his motivator for his action plan in Wendy’s growth development. As the fast-food industry is growing, Wendy’s has remained committed to providing the highest quality and freshness foods while assuring competitive prices where quality and......

Words: 799 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Wendy's

... Anderson II. TIME CONTEXT:  2007 III. PROBLEM STATEMENT  In 2006, Wendy’s net income dropped by 58% and closed 199 restaurants during the year.  High competition remains with other fast-food restaurants (McDonalds, Burger King and Yum Brands)  Wendy’s is facing the prospect of being sold to Triarc owned by its largest institutional shareholder, Peltz.  Under the pressure also of Pelz, Wendy’s sold Tim Horton’s even though it was a profitable company in the coffee and doughnuts business and Wendy’s has a plan to expand by penetrating breakfast food market.  With the decreased sales and number of stores, and the influence of Pelz, the CEO is faced with the options to succumb to the demands of Pelz to sell the company or continue with the comprehensive Revitalization Plan. IV. STATEMENT OF THE OBJECTIVES  To be able to increase market share and increase income by 30% within 5 years by growing franchise ownership and controlling operating costs with heightened commitment to quality products and services and expanded meal and food offerings. V. AREAS OF CONSIDERATIONS Strengths           Global brand 1st to offer 99 cent value menu Number 1 in consumer taste tests and brand awareness Healthier food selections 122 new restaurant in North America Expert Management Atmosphere Better compensation package for employees Reduced labor costs Speed of service Weaknesses  The fingertip in chili incident dropped the sales in 2005  Failed marketing strategy......

Words: 744 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Finger Wharf

...the changing significance of a specific heritage site for the local area and beyond. The Finger Wharf building and site has had throughout its existence had a changing significance on the local area and beyond. Designed by Henry Walsh and completed in 1915, the building was made to facilitate and bring order to Sydney and Australia’s maritime activity. The building has held significance in the areas of trade, military, immigration and culture. Even prior to this the site had many uses for aborigines such as a burial site and the new European colonisers. After its use expired the building was saved from destruction and refurbished into an area of thriving restaurants, accommodation and art, making it a must visit destination for locals and tourists. The Finger Wharf’s foremost significance was in trade. The Sydney Harbour Trust’s main objective for the building was to control the trade in Sydney’s waters. Even prior to the completion of the building shipping had already begun trading on the site in 1912. With its completion in 1915 the building played a significant role in the development of the young Australian and local economies particularly its role in the “long boom.” The building to facilitate its important role in trade was equipped with some of the first ever-electrical lifts, cranes and conveyor belts in NSW. While wool was a key part of the economic activity at the Finger Wharf, agricultural goods such as wheat and dairy from the country areas of NSW were......

Words: 1372 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Gold Star Chili

...Chapter 4 Case 3 III. Gold Star Chili: Customer and Market Knowledge Although no discussion questions are raised at the end of the case (a disturbing fact for some students who are overly focused on getting the “right answer”) some issues for discussion would seem obvious. Customer and Market Focus Strengths • Gold Star has segmented its customers into three groups -- franchisees, restaurant customers, and retail customers. They have carefully defined the characteristics of each. • To learn from customers, the company relies on face-to-face contacts, focus groups, customer comment cards, customer surveys, and structured meetings. Each of these is tailored to meeting the need of franchisees at various stages of growth of the franchise. Some of these include: - Geo-demographic analysis of locations prior to building - Use of Franchise Service Representatives (FSR’s) to stay in touch with franchisees and their needs when placing orders - Opportunities to listen and learn through regular franchise meeting and training sessions - Regular comprehensive surveys using questionnaires • Evaluation of product and service features takes place through formal and informal means, such as: - Informal determination of product and service features through quarterly and semi-annual meetings, daily and weekly phone calls to FSR’s, and discussions with delivery personnel. - Store managers’ contacts and discussion with “regular” customers - Annual......

Words: 503 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Bosse vs Chili Case Study

...Case Name: Bosse vs. Brinker Restaurant d/b/a Chili’s Which court is making this decision? Who did what to whom? Bosse was a customer who ran out on his bill. Another patron, who is unknown, chased Bosse. During the chase the unknown patron called and informed an employee at Chili’s of the situation, who then called 911. While being chased Bosse was involved in an auto accident and was injured. What relief (claim) was sought by plaintiff in the lower court? Bosse claims the unknown patron was working on behalf of the restaurant, he therefor caused the accident which makes the restaurant liable for damages. What was the lower court’s decision? And, if applicable, the Court of Appeals’ decision? N/A Who prevailed in the lower court(s)? N/A What is the specific legal question, based on what facts, is this court is being asked to address? Did the unknown patron’s actions create an agency when they contacted Chilis? There is no genuine issue to prove Bosse claim of the patron working as an agent for Chili’s. What law(s) and specifically, which legal element(s) is (are) at issue? The common law of agency. Specifically the implied agency due to the patron pursuing the plaintiff. What is the court’s reason (interpretation) for the application of, change in, or exception to the law? There was no implied agency due to no consent, no control and there was no relationship or benefit for the restaurant, between them and the unknown......

Words: 364 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Wendy's

...Restructuring Timeline Executive Summary Wendy’s is currently the world’s 2nd largest quick-service hamburger company, operating 1,438 stores and franchising 5,177 store in the U.S. and 27 countries world-wide. This highly competitive segment of the restaurant industry forces Wendy’s to compete not only in terms of food quality, price, convenience and value; but also for customers, employees and real estate. In 2011 and 2012, Wendy’s sales were $2,431 million and $2,505 million respectively. Despite this increase in sales, Wendy’s profit margin was only .2%. The major areas of concern for Wendy’s are its high cost of goods sold, high costs related to the owner ship of stores, its failure to communicate its brand and customer service. To combat these problems, ABC Consulting proposes that Wendy’s cut 100 underperforming store, and sell off franchise stores. Additionally, Wendy’s should reevaluate its employee training and retrain all employees on customer service standards. Create standardized procedures for preparing food, and retrain employees on customer service and finally increase product offerings consistent with Wendy’s goal of offering quality food - fast. Background Wendy’s was started in 1969 when Dave Thomas opened his first restaurant in Columbus Ohio. While other companies were selling frozen mass-produced products, Wendy’s sought to set a new standard preparing fresh, made-to-order food. Wendy’s had 6500 stores operating world-wide......

Words: 7615 - Pages: 31

Premium Essay

Wendy’s Chili: a Costing Conundrum

...UVA-C-2206 WENDY’S CHILI: A COSTING CONUNDRUM What happens to a successful company when it loses its founder, senior chairman, advertising icon, and beloved leader? That was the question being asked about Wendy’s International, Inc., in January 2002 after Dave Thomas, 69, passed away from cancer. In the words of Jack Schuessler, the company’s chairman and CEO, “Dave was our patriarch. He was the heart and soul of our company.” Without him, the company would never be the same. However, Dave Thomas left behind a legacy about values, ethics, product quality, customer satisfaction, employee satisfaction, community service and shareholder value that provided a solid foundation on which to continue the success the company had experienced for more than thirty years. Still, the patriarch was gone, and the future was uncertain. How It Began Wendy’s International, Inc., was founded by R. David Thomas in Columbus, Ohio, in November 1969. Prior to that time, Thomas had purchased an unprofitable Kentucky Fried Chicken franchise in the Columbus area, turned it around, and subsequently sold it back to Kentucky Fried Chicken at a substantial profit. He then became a cofounder of Arthur Treacher’s Fish & Chips. So, at the time he founded Wendy’s, Thomas was no stranger to the quick-service restaurant industry. Although he had been involved with businesses specializing in chicken and fish, Thomas’s favorite food was hamburgers, and he frequently complained that there was no...

Words: 4194 - Pages: 17

Free Essay

Bussiness Case Study Wendy's

...presented here is my own and is not copied from any source. Student's signature: | | Part (II): TUTOR'S REMARKS (to be completed by tutor) | Tutor name: | Signature: | Date TMA received: | Date returned: | TUTOR'S REMARKS: | Marks Allocatedto TMA | STUDENT MARK | 20 | For content : a maximum of 20 marks | Marks deducted for lang. & communication errors: a maximum of 4 marks | Earned Mark | | | | | LB 160 TMA * This TMA01 contains 2 parts. You should answer both parts. * The value of TMA is 20 points. * The mark assigned to each part is 10 points. __________________________________________________________________________________ PART 1 (10 points) Q. Write a SWOT analysis for the case study provided below in about 300 – 400 words. Analyze and propose solutions to the problem. The Sweet Dreams Motel – Far North Queensland The Sweet Dreams Motel is a 40-unit, no-frills operation in the less scenic part of a major Queensland resort town. The owner, Mr Smith, firmly believes that there is a need for his style of low-cost family accommodation amid the luxury and beauty of the area. His rooms are large, family-style rooms (there is no television, for example). Although there is plenty of room for future expansion, the grounds are fairly bare with a bit of landscaping, but mostly grass. Mr. Smith can serve breakfast to the rooms and provides tea-making facilities. There are now a lot of good restaurants and......

Words: 1618 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Wendy's or Vapiano

...Business School, Intercultural Management and Leadership Wendy’s or Vapiano? In initial Research: How companies present quality of their products and services to the public Prepared by Svitlana Kyazimova Vienna, 2010 Table of content Introduction 1. What are my expectations from the restaurants? 2. Wendy’s valuation 3. Vapiano valuation 4. Personal experience of being a Vapiano customer Conclusion Introduction A quality is an attribute or a property. Subjectively, something might be good because it is useful, because it is beautiful, or simply because it exists. Determining or finding qualities therefore involves understanding what is useful, what is beautiful and what exists. Commonly, quality can mean degree of excellence, as in, "a quality product" or "work of average quality". The quality of a product or service refers to the perception of the degree to which the product or service meets the customer's expectations. The quality management and quality control should be performed in all the levels. The scheme bellow demonstrates how the quality management functions in the Fast-food restaurants: In my initial research I would like to investigate two companies from the same business sector which is Entertainment and the industry is Restaurants. My choice fell on fast food Wendy’s from Wendy's/Arby's Group (USA/Canada) and Vapiano International......

Words: 2391 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Finger Prints

...Fingerprints Fingerprint is an impression of marking something superficial by the last joint of the thumb or other finger(s). Fingerprint identification is one of the most distinguished biometrics. It has been used for so many years for its efficiency and reliability. This type of identification is used by law enforcement and immigration. FBI (2013). Fingerprints helps to see if the suspect’s has been arrested or had any other convictions before. It also helps to recognize missing people, amnesia victims, and unknown dead people if they are in the criminal files. Michal Lyman (2014) A fingerprint looks like series of dark lines that symbolize the high, topping portion of the friction ridge skin, while the valleys between these ridges looks like white space and are the low, narrow portion of the friction ridge skin. FBI (2013) Fingerprints was publically used for first time in 1858 by Sir William Herschel who was a British chief administrative officer for the Hooghly district, Bengal, India. In 1877, he asked permission to his bosses to identify prisoners by using fingerprints. United States recognized the used of fingerprint for the first time in 1882, by Gilbert Thompson. In 1903, New York State prison system used this method of identification for criminals. After this, fingerprints was stablished in all U.S. There are two types of prints. One is the Latent or Patent Fingerprint. This one is invisible. It is created by oil and grease make by the body, and......

Words: 969 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Chili Prices

...Macroeconomics Short Essay 1 Chili Prices hot on short supply and rising demand PK KRISHNAKUMAR & JAYASHREE BHOSALE, ET Bureau Jul 16, 2015, 04.00AM IST Tags: * (Meanwhile, keeping with…) KOCHI/PUNE: Chili prices are getting hotter due to supply squeeze and rising demand. The prices of the largest exported spice from India are hovering around Rs 95-Rs 100 a kg, 20 per cent more than the prices a year ago, and may race to a new high depending on the demand, trade insiders say Chili crop was down by 15 per cent-20 per cent due to erratic rains last year. This along with high export demand in the end of 2014-15 seems to have dried up the stock, particularly in Andhra Pradesh — the largest chili producing region. "At present the cold storages in Guntur are showing 30 per cent-40 per cent deficiency," said Ravipati Peraiah, MD at Vijayakrishna Spice Farm, a dry chili manufacturer and supplier based in Bellary. The annual chili production in the country is about 13-14 lakh tonne. Rising prices have led to hoarding, which in turn affects supply and boost prices further. "About 75 per cent of the available stock is with the traders and only the rest is with the farmers," said Venkat Rosaiah, president of Guntur Chilli Commission Agents Association. "Heavy purchase by China and Bangladesh last year has created pressure on the stock and has lifted the price. But if Andhra gets good rainfall in the coming weeks, the prices will cool." The prices are expected to go......

Words: 839 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Wendy's Chili

...UVA-C-2206 WENDY’S CHILI: A COSTING CONUNDRUM What happens to a successful company when it loses its founder, senior chairman, advertising icon, and beloved leader? That was the question being asked about Wendy’s International, Inc., in January 2002 after Dave Thomas, 69, passed away from cancer. In the words of Jack Schuessler, the company’s chairman and CEO, “Dave was our patriarch. He was the heart and soul of our company.” Without him, the company would never be the same. However, Dave Thomas left behind a legacy about values, ethics, product quality, customer satisfaction, employee satisfaction, community service and shareholder value that provided a solid foundation on which to continue the success the company had experienced for more than thirty years. Still, the patriarch was gone, and the future was uncertain. How It Began Wendy’s International, Inc., was founded by R. David Thomas in Columbus, Ohio, in November 1969. Prior to that time, Thomas had purchased an unprofitable Kentucky Fried Chicken franchise in the Columbus area, turned it around, and subsequently sold it back to Kentucky Fried Chicken at a substantial profit. He then became a cofounder of Arthur Treacher’s Fish & Chips. So, at the time he founded Wendy’s, Thomas was no stranger to the quick-service restaurant industry. Although he had been involved with businesses specializing in chicken and fish, Thomas’s favorite food was hamburgers, and he frequently complained that there was no...

Words: 4194 - Pages: 17